No one playing anymore?
You're missing out.
Haven't had heaps of time to play, still only level 14, but my earlier assumption that melee was going to suck has been proven completely wrong. It's a lot of fun. I've just recently got Blitz and Blade Arc and these skills make the Soldier fucking awesome. Combined with a bit of a Demolitionist's abilities to stop some mobs in their tracks and my bro is a lot of fun to play.
Here's the thing - this feels different to Diablo 3, in a really good way. While D3 had super fast paced action combat, which for what it was, wasn't terribad, GD makes you think about shit. You think about spacing, about timing. There's a lot of random shit going on in the fights, attacks can miss, or be deflected. Suddenly that plan you had to take out these 30 zombies and elite pack coming towards you isn't going so well, and it's oh fuck oh fuck oh fuck time. I love that shit.
The kiting to heal mechanic is fine. Sure, you can run away and come back, but some of the mobs self heal as well, so usually it's kind of like just an admission that your previous strategy didn't work and you have to try a new one. So far the only fights that I've found a bit silly are boss ones, where it seemed there was only 2 tactics - kite and shoot, or run in for some quick damage with melee and then run out. BUT, the fights are tense, and in that sense I think they are fun.
I've also got to say, the encounter set ups are excellent. You can tell that they have actually put a lot of thought into which mobs get grouped together, and how this is going to force your tactics one way or another. It keeps the combat interesting and allows for using a wide variety of different skills to win.
I've only died like maybe 3 times, and that was because I was being a stupid, go for glory commando that I am.
The maps are excellently randomized. Each time I play there might be a different cave somewhere that I couldn't get to before. They're also pretty large and offer a lot of fun just in terms of exploration. Loot has been pretty good so far, but I think they need more variety in what melee weapons do. Maybe I just haven't found enough loot to comment on this yet though.
To summarize - this game is as awesome as I thought it would be. Really hoping they can keep the quality of what is in the alpha consistent throughout the beta and on to the full release.