B, I agree about the open updates. Sometimes people would rather have a few choices before them. I think the semi-open choices are best. For example, with this update just put down to approach the skeletons, leave this area, or investigate the tombs and then leave it open for any other suggestions.
I personally like the freedom of the open updates. As long as we don't get all open updates all the time, we should be fine.
Semi open updates are still open updates.