Putting the 'role' back in role-playing games since 2002.
Donate to Codex
Good Old Games
  • Welcome to rpgcodex.net, a site dedicated to discussing computer based role-playing games in a free and open fashion. We're less strict than other forums, but please refer to the rules.

    "This message is awaiting moderator approval": All new users must pass through our moderation queue before they will be able to post normally. Until your account has "passed" your posts will only be visible to yourself (and moderators) until they are approved. Give us a week to get around to approving / deleting / ignoring your mundane opinion on crap before hassling us about it. Once you have passed the moderation period (think of it as a test), you will be able to post normally, just like all the other retards.

Torment Torment: Tides of Numenera Pre-Release Thread [ALPHA RELEASED, GO TO NEW THREAD]

Kirtai

Augur
Joined
Sep 8, 2012
Messages
1,124
No reason to assume there are a shit ton of such beings in the universe. And even if it were the case, the idea that a higher capacity sentience inevitably makes beings of lower intelligence obsolete is not a justifiable inference. The theoretical capacity for any such entity to control a person completely does not mean it will choose to exert it, let alone exert it across the entirety of the species. We can theoretically train monkeys to be our servants, but we don't (or do so rarely [perhaps too rarely?]).
No, but we also don't have the ability to make imaginary monkeys in our heads that are indistinguishable from real monkeys either. How can you tell if you're an actual physical being or a mental simulation used by a transapient to predict the behaviour of one? Or maybe you're just a daydream. And does the difference actually matter?
 

hiver

Guest
They are completely overwhelmed by all the forces surrounding them, forces that are possessed more often then not by entities with goals far beyond human comprehension, and that could simply logically brainwash all humanity and control them like ants, in a snap
:lol:
Any proof of this aside from your limited moronic self indulgence? Anywhere?

Doesnt the fact that they are "beyond human comprehension" mean anything to you human imbecile?

I've explained it 10 times already. Learn to read more than 10 lines you son of a silly person. And if you are not fine with my demonstration, then deconstruct it clearly.
You didnt explain shit. You just keep repeating the same stupid assumptions over and over and disregarding anything else.

To your stupid limited brain its all: there is 1 therefore it all MUST be 10.

Its a post apocalyptic setting you incredible dumbfucking idiot. Apocalypse! get it?
All were included in this apocalypse you fucking imbecile.The entities, the mutants, the nanites, the intelligences - everything. Not just current humans.

And there is nothing stating that any of these entities or intelligences are godlike you despicable brain turd.
Except you.

Nor that they have powers on magnitutes you invented because of your own stupidity.
 

hiver

Guest
hey, also throw in this doozy too:

First magic is limited : it's limited by a mysterious force that is ungraspable.

:lol: :hearnoevil: :retarded:


Also guys... did you notice he went and mentioned George RR martin to me?
:lol:

I thought youre all going to cream on that one hehehe
 

GueulEclator

Educated
Joined
Dec 4, 2012
Messages
44
Captain Shrek
Well, GueulEclator is talking about transcendence a whole lot ;)
Because apparently there is a whole lot of that in this setting, and science fiction in general. Except it's neither never logically exploited, or the author uses tons of deus ex machina and leaves much plot holes. My English vocabulary is limited, but I promise I'll come up with more synonym next time.
 

hiver

Guest
Ach... he needs actual question marks....


Ok, let me try and simplify the questions so you can understand them.

1. How and why are these intelligence or entities godlike and limitless in their powers - according to what we know about the setting?

2. How is it that magic is limited because it is a mysterious force that is ungraspable while apparent AIs and such entities are limitless because they are ungraspable?

3. What says that any of these entities can fully control humans, brainwash them and control them like ants, telepathically no less?

4. Why would they even need or want to... seeing how they are incomprehensible?

5. What proves that technology will always reach a step that is trans-human? I mean in this setting particularly and always being a key word here.

6. What proves there will be any disregard of the whole soul concept ?

7. What is a soul ?

8. What proves "they can just mess with the whole galaxy your in, at will." ?

9. What proves that "Let's face it, humans become obsolete after the technology reach a certain point," ?

10. What proves, that even if there are any transhumans in the game they are flawless and infallible or omnipotent? if they are not - what makes ordinary humans completely obsolete?



 

GueulEclator

Educated
Joined
Dec 4, 2012
Messages
44
Ach... he needs actual question marks....


Ok, let me try and simplify the questions so you can understand them.

1. How and why are these intelligence or entities godlike and limitless in their powers - according to what we know about the setting?

2. How is it that magic is limited because it is a mysterious force that is ungraspable while apparent AIs and such entities are limitless because they are ungraspable?

3. What says that any of these entities can fully control humans, brainwash them and control them like ants, telepathically no less?

4. Why would they even need or want to... seeing how they are incomprehensible?

5. What proves that technology will always reach a step that is trans-human? I mean in this setting particularly and always being a key word here.

6. What proves there will be any disregard of the whole soul concept ?

7. What is a soul ?

8. What proves "they can just mess with the whole galaxy your in, at will." ?

9. What proves that "Let's face it, humans become obsolete after the technology reach a certain point," ?

10. What proves, that even if there are any transhumans in the game they are flawless and infallible or omnipotent? if they are not - what makes ordinary humans completely obsolete?

Most of these I've answered in previous threads, but just for you illiterate I will provide a summary :

1-3-5-8-9-10 : all at the same time because they mean the exact same thing. The author of numenera said that there will be tons of scattered technology, from a billion years of different civlization. This scattered technology comprise the following :
- Full Brain Reading devices : device can read thought, memories...
- Full brain control : Virus and devices that can completely take control of a brain, even a dead one. Therefore the device/organism is now in charge of your own spirit = you loose your individuality and you die
- Uber AI : An artficial intelligence that outmatch the human brain in every respect, and can connect itself to...
...- Nanobots : Some of the swarms are controlled by an AI. They have the power to construct/deconstruct what you task them to. This logically means they can construct you a laboratory + robots+ more AI computer + more brain controlling device... if you give them the proper material.
- Uber virus : virus technology goes as far as controlling an entire human. Add to that that virus tends to reproduce themselves...
- Reality twisting technology : Not a lot of detail were leaked, But once you've reached the point were you can disregard physical law, reality doesn't mean anything anymore to you. In case your too stupid to understand, that means your pretty near what one would consider god like level (by today's standard)
-Solar/planetary reshaping : The sun should have made life on this planet impossible after so much time. The author himself said, that something along the lines of solar/magnetosphere modifications were made.
- Advanced Genetics : to the point where mutant ... are possible.
- Anti gravity fortress, massive electromagnetical fields...

By our current definition, many of these are trans human. And don't fucking dick around with this : FTL mixed with ultra advanced DNA mastery, with Uber AI, with realitu distortion is fucking tans-human.
If this isn't, than what is?
Now, there aren't just human in this solar system anymore. Everything would be fine if it was just about human : the rabble of men wouldn't be able to comprehend the technology they stumble upon, and would only be able to use it when it's plug and play.

But there are tans-dimensional beeing that are said to be far above human level in terms of intelligence/schemes. Also there are still working AI's that are also far above human analytical potential. Not to mention eventual more intelligent species (either aliens of modified organism). All these outmatch human mind. There are beings that can comprehend this technology, and even use the reality altering device on their own.
When such beings have access to all these remnants of technology, it's safe to assume they won't shy from using it far more efficiently than human will. And the authors did say they will.This potentially means access to massive brain controlling waves : by mixing the different technology I listed above. This also means that they can distort reality that an extend where they modify events at their will...

So yes, a simple human is fucked in this situation. He can't even grasp (as the authors said) the schemes of these guys. That means he won't have any incidence whatsoever, ANY. Considering all the huge forces at work in this setting, I find it difficult to believe that humans aren't already enthralled in 10 of them.
Not to mention the fact that humanity is still here. After billions of year of advance, you would have expected them to evolve genetically and bionically. Hell even today we are already speaking about enhancing our strenght/lifespan... in less than 50 years (don't believe me faggot? well read nature science more often).

I don't see the point of playing in a setting where : 1. You shouldn't even logically exist as a primitive human organism anymore. 2. You aren't in control of anything and are moved like a pawns by all the other entities that have access to un-imagninable technology.



2. Magic was always a different kind of shit than physics. Try waving your hand in the hair while saying ''abrafuckingcadabra'' to see if a pink poney appears before you. Try finding a leprechaun at the foot of a rainbow. Try to jump from your apartment to see if you can fly spontaneously (please try this). Magic is by definition IRRATIONAL.
That is the whole point of magic : It's a force that is fucking IRRATIONAL. It's convenient to a point where it makes no sense in a rational universe. A whole universe law is build around the fact that if you say ''PAKABOBUBA'' a rainbow rider will appear from the plane of fishpond hell. That's why I say it's mysterious. It's random, ultra specific for no reason of all the different atoms structure in the universe,only human-like sound wave + written diagrams on a piece of paper make them work.


4. Why would they need too? Why the fuck are we supposed to know why? The author just said that they will interfere. At that point, everything said in my 1-3-5-8-9-10 answer can happen (and should logically happen.


7. What is a soul : BEST QUESTION EVER. Honestly of all the question that you asked, it's the only one that isn't stupid. In real life, there is no answer, unless of course you have one (go ahead, I'll have a good laugh). In a fantasy setting, the soul is basically your immaterial self : the immortal imprint of your basic self, your consciousness... This soul is able to travel to destination, and is basically what you can call ''myself'', your individuality.
Except in this case we are not sure if they'll give it a clear definition. So let's assume there is none.
I did used the world soul, but By soul I was meaning your consciousness, yourself as an individual, your thought patterns... I used it because I had no better word. Except maybe brain. But brain also means reflex, pain and automatism, which isn't one could call personality.
 

hiver

Guest
Look...you incredible cretin... i didnt ask you for your assumptions nor for your interpretations. Ive been unfortunately reading that garbage for two pages now.

I asked you to prove-quote where any of that is actually written to be just like you say it will be - in the setting of numenera itself.

And you "forgot" this is post apocalyptic setting... again.

-edit-

answers 2,4 and 7 are complete failures, as are the rest until you prove any of it. And no, the rest are not completely the same thing. they are interdependent on each other, depending on the answers and nothing written about the setting says any of those are omnipotent entities - especially when we know this is post-apocalyptic setting.
 
Self-Ejected

Kosmonaut

Lost in Space
Joined
Jul 11, 2008
Messages
4,741
Location
CCCP
hey, also throw in this doozy too:



:lol: :hearnoevil: :retarded:


Also guys... did you notice he went and mentioned George RR martin to me?
:lol:

I thought youre all going to cream on that one hehehe
Kill yourself turdlicker.
 
Joined
Aug 28, 2012
Messages
997
Location
Dreams, where I'm a viking.
Project: Eternity Torment: Tides of Numenera
No reason to assume there are a shit ton of such beings in the universe. And even if it were the case, the idea that a higher capacity sentience inevitably makes beings of lower intelligence obsolete is not a justifiable inference. The theoretical capacity for any such entity to control a person completely does not mean it will choose to exert it, let alone exert it across the entirety of the species. We can theoretically train monkeys to be our servants, but we don't (or do so rarely [perhaps too rarely?]).
No, but we also don't have the ability to make imaginary monkeys in our heads that are indistinguishable from real monkeys either.

Speak for yourself...

How can you tell if you're an actual physical being or a mental simulation used by a transapient to predict the behaviour of one? Or maybe you're just a daydream. And does the difference actually matter?

We'll find out soon - http://io9.com/5950543/physicists-s...o-prove-that-we-live-in-a-computer-simulation
 

GueulEclator

Educated
Joined
Dec 4, 2012
Messages
44
Look...you incredible cretin... i didnt ask you for your assumptions nor for your interpretations. Ive been unfortunately reading that garbage for two pages now.

I asked you to prove-quote where any of that is actually written to be just like you say it will be - in the setting of numenera itself.

And you "forgot" this is post apocalyptic setting... again.

Ok, you're more idiotic than I expected. You probably didn't red shit about numenera and are spewing everything out of your ass :
about telepaty, brain reading and all that shit : http://www.numenera.com/distinguishing-it-from-magic/
About the sun modification : http://www.montecookgames.com/a-billion-years/
about dataweb, biomecanic creatures... : http://www.numenera.com/overview/
Also overall, tons of different element that I stated : http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1433901524/numenera-a-new-roleplaying-game-from-monte-cook
If you read all his development diary, you will find ll the rest.

Here's for you, you total waste of human resources.
 

toro

Arcane
Vatnik
Joined
Apr 14, 2009
Messages
14,817
Look...you incredible cretin... i didnt ask you for your assumptions nor for your interpretations. Ive been unfortunately reading that garbage for two pages now.

I asked you to prove-quote where any of that is actually written to be just like you say it will be - in the setting of numenera itself.

And you "forgot" this is post apocalyptic setting... again.

Ok, you're more idiotic than I expected. You probably didn't red shit about numenera and are spewing everything out of your ass :
about telepaty, brain reading and all that shit : http://www.numenera.com/distinguishing-it-from-magic/
About the sun modification : http://www.montecookgames.com/a-billion-years/
about dataweb, biomecanic creatures... : http://www.numenera.com/overview/
Also overall, tons of different element that I stated : http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1433901524/numenera-a-new-roleplaying-game-from-monte-cook
If you read all his development diary, you will find ll the rest.

Here's for you, you total waste of human resources.

Are you a masochist?
 

GueulEclator

Educated
Joined
Dec 4, 2012
Messages
44
Go ahead smartass, prove that I'm wrong. I was ready for all the irrational opposition when I began to criticizes mainstream sci-fi like this piece of crap potentially crappy setting (I give them one last benefit of the doubt).

Those sources are fucking relevant and state everything that I already wrote. So I'm waiting to see you struggle with a counter-demonstration, since I took the time to back everything.
 

hiver

Guest
Ahhh...what a dumbfuck...

ok.. BEND OVER!

Im going to tech you how to use quotes to prove your point!
hope you have some vaseline! Hold on toight!



Billion years? Has passed - you bleeding idiot. All these high technological empires have BLOODY FALLEN! How come if they were so fantastically omnipotent and flawless you fucking imbecile?
That means you fucking retard - that awesome powers do not exist anymore in their full potential and that they NEVER had capabilities you pulled out of your stupid ass.

As i said from the get go.


Humanity lives amid the remnants of eight great civilizations that have risen and fallen on Earth. These are the people of the Ninth World. This new world is filled with remnants of all the former worlds: bits of nanotechnology, the dataweb threaded among still-orbiting satellites, bio-engineered creatures, and myriad strange and wondrous devices.

Fallen, remnants - bits! DO YOU UNDERSTAND ENGLISH? DO YOU UNDERSTAND WHAT POST APOCALYPTIC MEANS?


In Numenera, you could conceivably use technology or even telepathy to access the memories (and even personality) stored in the brain of a dead person. You could have biological or technological means to animate a corpse, and even give it some kind of drive or will, accessing those prior memories and personality.
-
So it comes down to this: traditional voodoo zombie raised by the dark arts, or “walking dead” corpse, animated by a sophisticated virus that can activate nerve endings, muscles, and even memories? From the viewpoint of many people, this is nothing but a rather pedantic splitting of hairs,

Again, not a fucking word about this being readily available or limitless. NO FUCKING WORD "UBER" anywhere.

Even though the current inhabitants live at about a Medieval level of technology, the leftover remnants of these advanced societies lie all around them. Some of these are extremely helpful: advanced tools, valuable means of communication and learning, transportation, defenses, and weapons. Others are dangerous: genetically altered monstrosities, flesh-warping radiation, creatures transplanted from distant stars, and clouds of out-of-control nanobots, just to name a few.

Again - not a fucking word about limitless possibilities.
For your fucking dumbfucking information just saying nano-bots DOES NOT MEAN THEY ARE CAPABLE OF ABSOLUTELY ANYTHING.

Just saying there is an AI does not fucking mean it is a god!

Faeries, spirits, or traditional myth: While extradimensional, incorporeal entities exist in the Ninth World as a result of the prior worlds’ inhabitants experimenting with gates and other means to access other levels of reality, that doesn’t make them sylphs, ghosts, angels, or demons.
I might create something that seems very much like a spirit dwelling in a lake, but I don’t have to cleave to the myths of selkies or the nymphs when I do so. In fact, the situation offers me the great gift of creative space in order to do something different with the idea.

No fucking word about uber powers.



The Benefits of Limitations

Strangely, I have found that putting even the slightest limitations on the setting (and more specifically, the power behind the setting–the causes of all the perceived effects) has broadened it, not diminished it.

Somehow, imagining the power it would take to work with gravity, material strength, power resources, and other factors makes putting a floating city in the sky more interesting than having it just be the result of some powerful spell.

It encourages me to think about the strange-looking gravity repulsors on the bottom of the city, and what the effects might be of being near them. It makes me think about the invisible force-field supports and bridges that connect the towers of glass, constantly repaired by fields of nanobots, so that they can take virtually any insane shape I can conceive. It makes me think about what might come to live in such a city after its creators are gone.
Spending time trying to imagine these–unimaginable–advanced civilizations that could build (almost) anything they wished spurs on creativity in ways that thinking about powerful wizards who could accomplish anything never did. Don’t get me wrong.

This isn’t a condemnation of traditional fantasy. I love that stuff (obviously). But right now, I’m head over heels about ultra-advanced technology and the setting its remnants can provide.


Now... do us all a favor and go outside, to some black hood, if you have any close by - and wear a sign saying I HATE NIGGERS.
 

hiver

Guest
:lol:

-edit-
damn, my bushido doesnt let me enjoy this for a long time....

let me just say...



ronML.png
 

hiver

Guest
Damn... even Tommy is here! wooo!

Hey Tommy! What can change the nature of the man?
 

Tommy Wiseau

Arcane
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
9,424
What *is* the nature of a man?
 

As an Amazon Associate, rpgcodex.net earns from qualifying purchases.
Back
Top Bottom