The Mysterious Mystery of the Codex Murders

[Viata]

And I think I remember Viata trying to accuse me through some very convoluted method. I think he is trying too hard. Perhaps he wisened up to the whole 'active poster' alibi and has gone overboard with it.

I'd pretty much kill you and waste my time on people who hardly post, as they would hardly defend themselves.

The orders were sent to Mr. Pink after I left the post.

How do you know that? There's 0 indication if the orders were sent before or after that.

Someone is trying to set me up with very crude and obvious fallacies

Maybe it's you who is leaving very obvious clues.

Come to think of it, he was the first one to support lynching a detective, was he not?

You are one of those who supported lynching a detective too, don't play the saint here.

I do not fear your accusation. If I die, that's it then. At least I know I found one of the killers and that's enough for me.

 

[Nevill]

I'd pretty much kill you and waste my time on people who hardly post, as they would hardly defend themselves.

You can't, because the priest is still in the game, and I specifically asked him to heal me.

I find it not surprising that I wasn't targeted this night. Tigranes said the most active users are the most likely victims. As I asked the priest to cover me, Tigranes was chosen instead.

I suppose it will be between me and taxalot the next night.

How do you know that? There's 0 indication if the orders were sent before or after that.

He said he would update after everyone sends him the orders.

The vault boy and the pillow are clear nods to my posts. It does not take a genius to put 2 and 2 together.

Maybe it's you who is leaving very obvious clues.

You are one of those who supported lynching a detective too, don't play the saint here.

Yes, but you went after him first, helping achieve the critical mass. I supported Tigranes' school of thought that it would be better to have a victim to have something to go on, and I think it still holds true. A shame he was a detective, though, I wanted to know your colors before I accuse you, and now I have to do it blind.

It might be an attempt to set you up, given the 'enmity' between us, but if you are goaded that easily, it would be a boon to have you lynched. No offense.

 

[taxalot]

I'd like to point out that I bought Fallout 4 and the season pass. If anything , that makes me a potential victim. I am asking for the priests protection.

 

[Grimgravy]

Well, that was bloody. Two more bodies.

What new clues did we find?
"Casual, Casual"
Pip boy bobble head
Whomp sound a pillow used for murder

from before
"He scaled to our level."
eaten body

I'll see what you guys cook up in the morning.

 

[Nevill]

Do the killers even know who's the detective?

Of course not.

I meant it as in 'he was quick to support killing someone right off the bat'.

 

[a bear named spigot]

hmm be on the lookout for someone with really strong arms that he could use to smother someone

also be wary of anyone with that look in their eyes

 

[Viata]

Do the killers even know who's the detective?

Of course not.

I meant it as in 'he was quick to support killing someone right off the bat'.

Because before Duraframe's accusation, there was 0 accusation, right?

As I asked the priest to cover me, Tigranes was chosen instead.

Because the Priest posted here: "I'll heal you, Nevill", right? You got 0 proof the Priest covered you.

He said he would update after everyone sends him the orders.

Which was 5 hours before your *hides pillow* post. How can you prove it was send after your post? The only person who knows the time the orders were sent was the killers themselves and the priest. The funny thing about this *hides pillow* is how before that post, you didn't ever post an action.

to have you lynched.

So be it. I'm still right and hope people see it after they know they hanged another innocent again.

 

[Viata]

Do the killers even know who's the detective?

Of course not.

I meant it as in 'he was quick to support killing someone right off the bat'.

Oh yeah, about this "quick to support killing someone", here is your first post, Nevill:

I will support Tigranes' case and blame taxalot

Funny how the world works.

 

[Nevill]

Because before Duraframe's accusation, there was 0 accusation, right?

Of Excom? Yes, I don't remember any.

Because the Priest posted here: "I'll heal you, Nevill", right?

No, that would be stupid.

It is not the first time I see you appealing to some kind of warped logic.

You got 0 proof the Priest covered you.

Of course I have 0 proof. I don't see your point.

Which was 5 hours before your *hides pillow* post. How can you prove it was send after your post?

Prove it? I don't need to prove anything, because proof does not exist in this game until you kill the person in question. All there is before that are some assumptions, and nothing else.

It is easy to infer the orders were sent after my post, as it would be a major coincidence for the killers to mention a pillow, and it would be pretty strange for me to post something like 'I DID IT, HANG ME' on a forum, regardless of my allegiance.

By demanding proof when you know there is none and there can not be one, you do not exactly make yourself sound very convincing.

Mind you, I still have doubts about your guilt, it's just you are making the killers' job easier.

 

[Nevill]

It is easy to inter the orders were sent after my post

Coincidentally, that rules out Corporate_Jew_Master. He wasn't active then.

Everyone who was active at that time, though, is doubly suspect.

 

[Viata]

Because before Duraframe's accusation, there was 0 accusation, right?

Of Excom? Yes, I don't remember any.

I didn't say Excom, I said about accusations. If I was quick to jump on, like you did, I'd have accused the same person as you and Tigranes.

 

[Nevill]

Yes, this is why I say that if you are guilty, it was a job well done.

 

[Viata]

So says the guy who is quick to support accusation.

 

[Nevill]

Of course. If I were a criminal, I would not risk attracting fire by blaming people left and right. Chances are, they will push back and when the suspect numbers get reduced, someone is going to remember everything.

I did a lot of punch throwing to see how people would react. From the reactions I got I can now safely say that I have less doubts about some people than about others.

You were not the first and not the last. You may be a run-off-the-mill innocent, or you may be someone trying to mingle. Still unsure about you, you are too obvious to be a criminal.

 

[Hoaxmetal]

*rattles angrily in his coffin*

 

[Corporate_Jew_Master]

Orders were given after I went to sleep, it seems and I slept pretty late.

We are most likely looking for someone in a kwan or at least non-euro timezone.

Who has been very vocal about Fallout 4 lately?

 

[Viata]

Who has been very vocal about Fallout 4 lately?

Ignore FO4. I don't think the order was "I kill him while he was playing FO4".

 

[Corporate_Jew_Master]

Who has been very vocal about Fallout 4 lately?

Ignore FO4. I don't think the order was "I kill him while he was playing FO4".

Looks like it was to me.

 

[Corporate_Jew_Master]

Also, the big vault boy head implies a big head to disguise and the murder also took great physical strength.

Like that of a bear.

I ACCUSE SPIGGOT.

 

[Jim the Dinosaur]

My take is that the two murderers killed each other simultaneously in a fargo-esque disagreement and the priest moved them to separate locations to sodomize them in peace lay them to rest.

 

[Nevill]

Ok, we need to pick a target and stick to it.

a bear named spigot, Jim the Dinosaur, or Viata. Pick your poison.

We need 4 votes for this.

taxalot, Grimgravy, what are your thoughts?

 

[Duraframe300]

After much consideration I ACCUSE Grimgravy.

He takes a very observing approach, holding himself at a distance as to not attract suspicion.

If we have to decide though I will change my vote to Viata (Though I'm not sure he is a killer)

 

[Tigranes]

Fallout 4? FALLOUT 4? THIS IS SCANDALOUS, EVERYTHING SAID ABOUT ME IS UNTR-

*croak*

 

[taxalot]

I'm going to catch up on everything that was said during my hard day of work, and I will see who deserves to die.

 

[taxalot]

Okay.

I am among the shocked here to see Hoaxmetal been offed. I am also shocked to hear that he is a casual, and that makes me a logical target for the killers if they follow a pattern. I'm a vocal Fallout 3 defender in a "it's not that terrible" , and although I have never played it, I have bought Fallout 4 and the season pass.

While I do realize this gives cause for my murder to happen, I think we all have to be open about everything for the entirety of the group to survive. Still, I'd like the priest to give a close watch on me.

I am still not a believer in the amount of posts being a clue to who is a murderer and who is a saint. As I have already stated, this train of thought can be used to say whatever your purpose is : a murderer has an interest in being vocal, in being silent, and in being middle ground.
Therefore, we have to rely on other options.

a bear named spigot , this time the victim was not eaten, merely brutally murdered. Strange. Is it because I thought the last murder clearly identified you that you changed the pattern and didn't eat a leg or two this time ? You are still a suspect in my book. But I will not accuse you. Not right now. Not yet. There is still time for an investigation to be conducted, and it should be conducted. Still, you should defend yourself.

Anyone should, in fact.

Which brings me to my next suspect. And this one is going to hurt a lot. I've got very confused feelings for you, Nevill .

No, not these kind of feelings. But you are among the most vocal... in my defense, without much proof. This is odd. Suspicious. As if you're trying to buy my vote with a new friendship. It could be that you genuinely trust me. It could be, and I have nothing to accuse you of as of yet, except maybe asking me a few posts ago to decide on whom we should vote out. That's a bit premature. It gives warning bells, like in a cheap made-for-TV movie when a family moves out to a nearby town and oh my god, this neighbour, he's SUPER friendly and so nice to us, what could go wrong ! You know what happens in the movie afterwards. You know it, don't you, Neville ?
I won't vote for you, Neville. Not yet. As a former suspect, I need everyone's support. But I need to ask you : why do you think I'm that innocent ? Can you give a plausible explanation ?