Putting the 'role' back in role-playing games since 2002.
Donate to Codex
Good Old Games
  • Welcome to rpgcodex.net, a site dedicated to discussing computer based role-playing games in a free and open fashion. We're less strict than other forums, but please refer to the rules.

    "This message is awaiting moderator approval": All new users must pass through our moderation queue before they will be able to post normally. Until your account has "passed" your posts will only be visible to yourself (and moderators) until they are approved. Give us a week to get around to approving / deleting / ignoring your mundane opinion on crap before hassling us about it. Once you have passed the moderation period (think of it as a test), you will be able to post normally, just like all the other retards.

The Japs do everything better

The Japanese control the RPG business

  • Yes

    Votes: 38 55.9%
  • Larian will save us

    Votes: 30 44.1%

  • Total voters
    68

Hell Swarm

Learned
Joined
Jun 16, 2023
Messages
2,144
CAMILLE BIDAN IS A TEENAGE BOY!
who? never used him.
i only field cute girls and cool guys like ryoma
Okay so Rayearth starts it's story with the school girls going to Tokyo tower.

So you're still wrong and you're a pedophile.
cross ange girls > rayearth girls.
And Ange is 16 and it's a school setting that highly sexualizes the characters.

I think that's enough evidence for how weird you JRPG freaks are. You're lusting after underage girls and trying to tell others they don't know the genre because you're so uninformed yourself it's the only way you can cope.

Sorry to derail this amazing thread guys. You can see the type of person who thinks Japanese games are better and why. And it's the young girls wearing skimpy bikinis pretending to be their friends. It's never the plot or the world building, it's just a disgusting fetish with as minimal gameplay as possible.
 

Reinhardt

Arcane
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
31,991
CAMILLE BIDAN IS A TEENAGE BOY!
who? never used him.
i only field cute girls and cool guys like ryoma
Okay so Rayearth starts it's story with the school girls going to Tokyo tower.

So you're still wrong and you're a pedophile.
cross ange girls > rayearth girls.
And Ange is 16 and it's a school setting that highly sexualizes the characters.

I think that's enough evidence for how weird you JRPG freaks are. You're lusting after underage girls and trying to tell others they don't know the genre because you're so uninformed yourself it's the only way you can cope.

Sorry to derail this amazing thread guys. You can see the type of person who thinks Japanese games are better and why. And it's the young girls wearing skimpy bikinis pretending to be their friends. It's never the plot or the world building, it's just a disgusting fetish with as minimal gameplay as possible.
whatever, pigdog.
you know, actually you probably googled ff7 and persona after all. just like you are googling right now. :dance:
 

Lord_Potato

Arcane
Glory to Ukraine
Joined
Nov 24, 2017
Messages
10,913
Location
Free City of Warsaw
And Ange is 16 and it's a school setting that highly sexualizes the characters.

I think that's enough evidence for how weird you JRPG freaks are. You're lusting after underage girls
Don't tell me you never lusted for a 16 year old girl... especially when you were 16 year old yourself.

Jrpg fans are not necessarily perverts. At least not all of them. Some just suffer from arrested development.
 

CryptRat

Arcane
Developer
Joined
Sep 10, 2014
Messages
3,625
-Final Fantasy 5 - The famous job system. 22 classes with great freedom at creating customized characters. Some of the trickier battles in the series.
-Romancing SaGa - Open world, complex systems, free-form weapon and magic customization options. High difficulty.
-EVO the search for Eden - Game where you start as a fish and level up by evolving into various life forms. Unique.
-Dragon Quest V - A game where you start as a kid adventuring with your dad, and end up as a dad adventuring with your kids. Catch monsters and add them to your team. Decently challenging.
-Shin Megami Tensei - YHWH nukes the world, survive the post-apocalypse by summoning, fusing, and bargaining with demons. Complex faction and alignment system.
None of these games do anything interesting and original for combat though. Their unique quirks are basically the same system with a different coat of paint. CRPGs had a much wider and more original range.
That's a terrible argument, there's a wide range in both cases yet in both cases the good ones are the one which just play (and look) like Wizardry or Pool of Radiance, everything else is garbage. Original Final Fantasy is great because it replaces the bad aspects of Ultima by better ones from Wizardry, and the same can basically be said about Dragon Quest 2. Later CRPGs are just Diablo-like shit with an annoying story while JRPGs abandonded the Ultima structure (advancing through following clues and using (key) items, some of my favourite CRPGs like Wasteland and Dragon Wars also use skills which is even better, Unlimited SaGa does that to a little extent) and the Wizardry balance, fun structure and fun balance of NES ones were progressively completely lost, also they included an annoying story too, that's common to all post-1995 RPGs from any part of the world. Also in general, japan or not, if it's not a game made to be just like Wizardry or Pool of Radiance then you can't even make your own party which means the game is automatically garbage.
 

Hell Swarm

Learned
Joined
Jun 16, 2023
Messages
2,144
you know, actually you probably googled ff7 and persona after all. just like you are googling right now. :dance:
I'm a mecha fan. I know the series because I also play SRT games and have since the GBA era. I don't need to google shit because I'm not some perv looking for young girls.
And Ange is 16 and it's a school setting that highly sexualizes the characters.

I think that's enough evidence for how weird you JRPG freaks are. You're lusting after underage girls
Don't tell me you never lusted for a 16 year old girl... especially when you were 16 year old yourself.

Jrpg fans are not necessarily perverts. At least not all of them. Some just suffer from arrested development.
Not all are perverts but the one who shit all over the west almost exclusively are. They have arrested development and an addiction to pornographic material that severely warps how they interact with media and how that bleeds into their interactions with people. I've seen people turn up to card game tournaments with lolicon sleeves and play mats and not understand why that's wrong. The acceptance and encouragement of this kind of material is a slippery slope that eventually ends in real world consequences. These people are abused and abusing themselves and repeat the cycle through things like early porn exposure fetishes.
That's a terrible argument, there's a wide range in both cases yet in both cases the good ones are the one which just play (and look) like Wizardry or Pool of Radiance, everything else is garbage. Original Final Fantasy is great because it replaces the bad aspects of Ultima by better ones from Wizardry, and the same can basically be said about Dragon Quest 2. Later CRPGs are just Diablo-like shit with an annoying story while JRPGs abandonded the Ultima structure (advancing through following clues and using (key) items, some of my favourite CRPGs like Wasteland and Dragon Wars also use skills which is even better, Unlimited SaGa does that to a little extent) and the Wizardry balance, fun structure and fun balance of NES ones were progressively completely lost, also they included an annoying story too, that's common to all post-1995 RPGs from any part of the world. Also in general, japan or not, if it's not a game made to be just like Wizardry or Pool of Radiance then you can't even make your own party which means the game is automatically garbage.
JRPGs of this era are mostly just Ultima and Wizardry clones of some fashion but dumbed down for a console audience. The JRPG structure cements during the SNES era and didn't change until Japan started doing open world games still following the same structure but now with massive empty fields to explore. The games listed as so similar you could mix and match them and no one would know they came from a different series. Is Dragon quest really that different to Final fantasy? You could look at strictly Games Workshop games of the era and have vastly deeper and varied games than all of Japan (or at least what we saw from Japan).

I'm not even saying Japan don't make fun games or their games are bad. It's just Japan as a culture are not innovative. They steal ideas from else where, refine them then slap an anime art style over the top. The nation was never very advanced and got used as a cheap puppet by the West until China took it's place. And that same 'Copy the white man but makes the eyes bigger" mentality is still all they have to offer.
 

Cross

Arcane
Joined
Oct 14, 2017
Messages
3,036
CRPGs are usually more complex than JRPGs in that era.
I suppose we'd have to answer what "era" we're speaking of.

In 1992, many classic CRPGs were released:

-Might and Magic 3 - bright, colorful, open world. Lots of classes but no real depth, gameplay loop is kill, loot, kill, combat is brainless, game is dead easy even on the 'hard' difficulty
-Ultima 7 - Neat interactive world, lots of dialogue, combat is simple & automated, basically no character customization.
-Darklands - Deep character building system, relatively simple combat, almost no progression. Deep, procedural open world. Sales disaster.
-Betrayal at Krondor - Interactive fiction. Barely a game. (*edit I was wrong, this was 1993)
-Wizardry 7 - Wonderful depth and complexity, but dungeon crawlers quickly died in the west while remaining popular in the east.
-Eye of the Beholder 2 - Dungeon crawler, has the D&D system but it's mostly meaningless, combat is just hack-in-slash and sidestepping.

In Japan, you got:

-Final Fantasy 5 - The famous job system. 22 classes with great freedom at creating customized characters. Some of the trickier battles in the series.
-Romancing SaGa - Open world, complex systems, free-form weapon and magic customization options. High difficulty.
-EVO the search for Eden - Game where you start as a fish and level up by evolving into various life forms. Unique.
-Dragon Quest V - A game where you start as a kid adventuring with your dad, and end up as a dad adventuring with your kids. Catch monsters and add them to your team. Decently challenging.
-Shin Megami Tensei - YHWH nukes the world, survive the post-apocalypse by summoning, fusing, and bargaining with demons. Complex faction and alignment system.

Even in that era, we can clearly see the western games are trying to tell stories first with heavily simplified mechanics, while the japanese games prioritized character customization, battle systems, and challenge. The exceptions were rejected by the west (Darklands) or were more akin to JRPGs (Wiz7).
Betrayal at Krondor, which you describe as "Interactive fiction. Barely a game." has more open exploration than Romancing SaGa which, contrary to what you claim, is not open world. Just because you have an overworld doesn't mean your game is actually open world.

Betrayal at Krondor also has a tacticool combat system that is more complex than the combat in any of the JRPGs you listed.
Your list also conveniently leaves out the most complex RPG released in 1992: Ultima Underworld, as well as the Goldbox games. :M
 

Reinhardt

Arcane
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
31,991
I'm a mecha fan. I know the series because I also play SRT games and have since the GBA era. I don't need to google shit because I'm not some perv looking for young girls.
wait, you mean you memorized age of every little boy and girl in srw series? and you call ME a pedo? nigga, you have serious problems.
 

MerchantKing

Learned
Joined
Jun 5, 2023
Messages
1,626
The funny thing is that the vast majority of Japanese rpgs are indistinguishable from rpgmaker slop. Maybe you have a comparatively few examples of games that are actually good and something worth playing.

Also only two options to the poll. That needs to be fixed.
 

Hell Swarm

Learned
Joined
Jun 16, 2023
Messages
2,144
I'm a mecha fan. I know the series because I also play SRT games and have since the GBA era. I don't need to google shit because I'm not some perv looking for young girls.
wait, you mean you memorized age of every little boy and girl in srw series? and you call ME a pedo? nigga, you have serious problems.
What happened to accusing me of googling stuff nigger? You can't admit you've been out played and not turn to calling people pedos because you have no defense for wanting to see 14 year olds in slim cut underwear.
The funny thing is that the vast majority of Japanese rpgs are indistinguishable from rpgmaker slop. Maybe you have a comparatively few examples of games that are actually good and something worth playing.
Where does JRPG end and RPG maker start?
 

jaekl

CHUD LIFE
Patron
Joined
May 1, 2023
Messages
1,653
Location
Canada
The japanese made dark souls so they get a pass from me even though I'm pretty pissed that they tricked me into thinking mega homos like squall and cloud from final fantasy were cool when I was a kid which is a form of child abuse.
 

Reinhardt

Arcane
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
31,991
What happened to accusing me of googling stuff nigger? You can't admit you've been out played and not turn to calling people pedos because you have no defense for wanting to see 14 year olds in slim cut underwear.

go away, creep. there is looking at animu booba and there is memorizing age and home address of every underage character you meet.
 

Silverfish

Arbiter
Joined
Dec 4, 2019
Messages
3,928
I've seen people turn up to card game tournaments with lolicon sleeves and play mats and not understand why that's wrong.

Depends on the card game. If it's YuGiOh or Pokemon, why are you playing that to begin with? If it's Magic, yes that's wrong and Plague Witch is the true waifu.

I'm pretty pissed that they tricked me into thinking mega homos like squall and cloud from final fantasy were cool when I was a kid which is a form of child abuse.

Cloud is gay, but Squall dodged being molested by a teacher through sheer autism. Pretty based. The gunsword is just a cherry on top.
 

tritosine2k

Erudite
Joined
Dec 29, 2010
Messages
1,700
I think about this stuff in terms of narcissistic fascination.

In the west you have programmer geniuses and hackathon stuff, same shit. And you'd be hard pressed to sexualize that so it's this stuff
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moe_(slang)
that's mainstream because you just can't make troon's and troon stuff mainstream. Or hackathon that's practically an OUTNERDING contest, lul.
 

Cheesedragon117

Educated
Joined
Sep 13, 2023
Messages
318
Location
Florida
It's utter buffoonery to keep GRPG separate from JRPG when the latter has been destroying the former's asshole for years. CRPGs are nearly dead. The Japs run a train on the industry day in, day out. You stop disrespecting JRPGs because they are the only thing keeping your genre alive, you weathered dying fucks. Submit.

Just think, within the span of three years two JRPGs will have won GOTY. Cope, dilate, etc. Just don't let the druid trick you. Don't forget the dark horse Stellar Blade (it will be on PC ctfd).

And 2025 is Monster Hunter Wilds. You have nothing. Some porn games and Bloodlines 2 made by the fucking Chinese Room. The JRPG subforum >>>> whatever you call this places. The Japs control your favorite genre.

Bow to your slant-eyed overlords.
old-man-toothless-laugh-i4h6gndv12hirld7.gif
If I knew you were going to make threads like these, I never would have ignored you.

These are the hard truths the Codexians need to hear, right now. Together we'll get through to them somehow...
 

OttoQuitmarck

Educated
Joined
Aug 1, 2023
Messages
433
Whenever I think of Dark Souls, I can't help but feel the enormity of what the game did to its players. It's akin to PST, but more. Especially because DS is so replayable, whereas PST is okay to be replayed once per 15 years.
Then they kept making them. More and more of the shockingly good stuff.

It's in everything they do. The japs are perfect gentlemen - the work on optimizations out of respect for the players, when the western lesbian devs stick dlss into the game and call it a day.
They don't offer difficulty settings in DS, respecting the player not to be a retard.
They make beautiful girls, respecting the player not to be a SJW soycuck.

The japs respect us. The western dev takes a shit on us and calls us toxic.
Dark souls optimized and polished? Bro you must be huffing crack cocaine heroin
 

As an Amazon Associate, rpgcodex.net earns from qualifying purchases.
Back
Top Bottom