Diablerie has officially become the main running joke of this LP. The first time it was suggested was almost exactly a year ago, on this page :
http://www.rpgcodex.net/forums/index.php?threads/lets-play-vtm-wild-nights-chapter-10.56987/page-5
I thought it was THE VASE. Cannibalism vs Pottery: Which is better and why? DISCUSS!!!
Phoning Costello is a terrible idea. If it turns out that the contact is actually a very powerful individual who can do a lot for us, outing that person will piss Vogler (and more importantly, his contact) off very much. Worse yet, we'll owe Costello a favour afterwards since we are clearly on neutral terms at best. Don't do it, fellas -
there is no good reason to call her. Vogler is offering us a position as his running-mate and has come to us in person - if we simply speak to the man, I am confident he'll just tell us who his mystery contact is, as his actions have shown he has put some measure of trust in us. That individual is likely the only was Vogler has a shot at becoming Prince.
Remember; it doesn't matter how popular the candidate is, how much people like him, etc. because in the end the Inner Circle is going to pick who the Inner Circle wants. If we decide we want Vogler in there because he has the best offer and will owe us the greatest debt if we do get him in*, it will be because we've managed to convince Camarilla envoy to choose him over candidates like Tarquin and Palomides. Popularity helps, it can even help a lot, but it won't seal the deal.
* Since diablerie seems to be what we all want if we could get away with it, getting an unlikely candidate in as Prince is the only shot at that. In return for doing our part to make a guy like Vogler (for example) Prince, they must offer up a Kindred of potent blood to increase our power, and a Tremere who can perform rituals to clean up our aura after the act. That's pretty much the only way I can envision us getting away with diablerie.
Anyways, I flop to
Negotiate with Vogler + D. This is the best offer we're going to get, and the sooner we mobilize to making this guy Prince and committing, the higher our chances of success. Furthermore, unlike our underlings, if we share the specifics of pulling off a Crazy Ventrue Scheme (tm) to drastically improve his chances, he will be 100% committed in helping us because we have a common goal. Eddie could rat us out... Cripps could rat us out... Vogler won't. He fucking wants this every bit as badly as we do, and he'll do whatever the fuck it takes to make it happen. I am positive that he has a few contacts in Swansea that can be of use to us.
Computer Gamer Refugee and
Kalin have shown me the shortcomings of the zany scheme I cooked up. We simply don't have the resources to pull such a thing off. HOWEVER, if we pool our resources with another Kindred, one who is 100% committed and united in their goals (which Vogler is), I am certain we could have a lot more options and methods in order to make a devious scheme far more likely. Gentlebros, we can't do this on our own - I really want to pull a scheme off, and I really want Tony to become a feared and powerful Kindred, and I think the way we do that is by combining everything we both have.
Think back to the Angelos plot: it took Karthik's Caecilian, Donnie, Erika, and Tony all combined to make it work. This is no different - if we want to have a chance of pulling off a bold and risky plot, we need Vogler in on it.