Incline GOTY 2024 Games List discussion [NO VOTING YET]

[luj1]

I made a simple and objective rule that's easy to apply - must contain animu degeneracy or be inspired by Dark Souls, my favorite game. Because Grimoire was too oldschool for me, an RPG historian, and ripped me 3 new assholes

 

[Grauken]

Arco is on the list and didn't have a codex thread until a month ago when I myself added it which no one posted on except me. Passageway of the Ancients has a 17 page thread with many at least trying the demo. So that <50 review rule isn't exactly something that would correlate to more votes.

And the list is as long as it is because of the dozens of anime games that literally no one plays.

If there's going to be a really long list on a forum about CRPGs, then all CRPGs should be on it, not 100 random anime JRPGs. The fact that random weebs on Steam gave reviews doesn't mean that's the same audience on the Codex.

I made a simple and objective rule that's easy to apply - 50 reviews or more. There will be junk in there, but it's a GOTY voting, it won't matter as long as people don't vote for them.

What you are saying is you already know which games the Codex likes and which ones are anime crap no one plays and can filter them. That's entirely subjective, you might as well just post the BosanskiSeljak personal GOTY list.

I mean, is it a GOTY voting on Codex or not, lots of the games in the list nobody on the codex ever discussed while some not on it had lots of eyes on it, feels weird to exclude something like Passageway of the Ancients that lots of Codexers actually talked about

 

[Haba]

Songs of Conquest is not an RPG.



And yeah, being on the RPG Codex GOTY 2024 should require that a thread exists for the game. If there isn't one, it should be eliminated from the vote.

 

[Infinitron]

Arco is on the list and didn't have a codex thread until a month ago when I myself added it which no one posted on except me. Passageway of the Ancients has a 17 page thread with many at least trying the demo. So that <50 review rule isn't exactly something that would correlate to more votes.

And the list is as long as it is because of the dozens of anime games that literally no one plays.

If there's going to be a really long list on a forum about CRPGs, then all CRPGs should be on it, not 100 random anime JRPGs. The fact that random weebs on Steam gave reviews doesn't mean that's the same audience on the Codex.

I made a simple and objective rule that's easy to apply - 50 reviews or more. There will be junk in there, but it's a GOTY voting, it won't matter as long as people don't vote for them.

What you are saying is you already know which games the Codex likes and which ones are anime crap no one plays and can filter them. That's entirely subjective, you might as well just post the BosanskiSeljak personal GOTY list.

I mean, is it a GOTY voting on Codex or not, lots of the games in the list nobody on the codex ever discussed while some not on it had lots of eyes on it, feels weird to exclude something like Passageway of the Ancients that lots of Codexers actually talked about

I think a thread existing on the Codex can be an alternative to the 50 review requirement.

 

[Lord_Potato]

Add Nemire that's missing too

And Passageway of the Ancients.

And Trail of Ayash

Jesus how many RPGs were cut to keep anime shit in lol Those are just the ones I played that I know about

Those three have less than 50 reviews on Steam. Passageway of the Ancients has 12, with Mixed ratings. If we add every single RPG to the list regardless of rating or review count, that's over two thousand entries.

There are games on the list that obviously aren't rpgs though...

 

[Maxie]

Arco is on the list and didn't have a codex thread until a month ago when I myself added it which no one posted on except me. Passageway of the Ancients has a 17 page thread with many at least trying the demo. So that <50 review rule isn't exactly something that would correlate to more votes.

And the list is as long as it is because of the dozens of anime games that literally no one plays.

If there's going to be a really long list on a forum about CRPGs, then all CRPGs should be on it, not 100 random anime JRPGs. The fact that random weebs on Steam gave reviews doesn't mean that's the same audience on the Codex.

I made a simple and objective rule that's easy to apply - 50 reviews or more. There will be junk in there, but it's a GOTY voting, it won't matter as long as people don't vote for them.

What you are saying is you already know which games the Codex likes and which ones are anime crap no one plays and can filter them. That's entirely subjective, you might as well just post the BosanskiSeljak personal GOTY list.

Imagine having a simple and objective rule like 'only put on the list what people actually nominated'

 

[StaticSpine]

Arco is on the list and didn't have a codex thread until a month ago when I myself added it which no one posted on except me. Passageway of the Ancients has a 17 page thread with many at least trying the demo. So that <50 review rule isn't exactly something that would correlate to more votes.

And the list is as long as it is because of the dozens of anime games that literally no one plays.

If there's going to be a really long list on a forum about CRPGs, then all CRPGs should be on it, not 100 random anime JRPGs. The fact that random weebs on Steam gave reviews doesn't mean that's the same audience on the Codex.

I made a simple and objective rule that's easy to apply - 50 reviews or more. There will be junk in there, but it's a GOTY voting, it won't matter as long as people don't vote for them.

This sounds like a rule for the sake of rule, not for the benefit of those who will actually vote.

Letting codexers nominate will lead to a more focused poll and greater satisfaction.

 

[Haba]

No nomination bullshit is necessary, just check all the RPGs released in 2024 and remove the ones that haven't been discussed at RPGKKKDEX, because how the fuck could RPGKKKDEX GOTY 2024 be a game that RPGKKKDEX has not discussed at all in the first place?

 

[StaticSpine]

just check all the RPGs

What is an RPG?

There's no agreement even on that. In General RPG Discussion any game that devs label as RPG is considered RPG nowadays.

 

[Darth Roxor]

just check all the RPGs

What is an RPG?

probably not songs of conquest

 

[Shaki]

Just to be clear, this is not a thread for discussing which games you intend to vote for. That will come later.

Thanks, I intend to vote for Drova and Skald.

 

[Shaki]

just check all the RPGs

What is an RPG?

Was answered long time ago: https://rpgcodex.net/forums/threads...-makes-a-game-not-an-rpg.130739/#post-6410396

 

[luj1]

Songs of Conquest is not an RPG.

This guy just doesn't know what he's doing, better to conserve your energy

 

[luj1]

No nomination bullshit is necessary, just check all the RPGs released in 2024 and remove the ones that haven't been discussed at RPGKKKDEX, because how the fuck could RPGKKKDEX GOTY 2024 be a game that RPGKKKDEX has not discussed at all in the first place?

That is exactly corect

But this insane cuck will never do that, because that would exclude the 80 hentai titles and Dark Souls inspired games he likes so much

 

[felipepepe]

I mean, is it a GOTY voting on Codex or not, lots of the games in the list nobody on the codex ever discussed while some not on it had lots of eyes on it, feels weird to exclude something like Passageway of the Ancients that lots of Codexers actually talked about

Ok, since people seem to want it I can add games that are nominated. Will add all the ones mentioned in this thread, including the Rogue Trader DLC.

But I still think this is outside the goals of a GOTY poll. If you want to support a game with 12 mixed reviews on Steam you should buy it and review it, not push to add it to the voting so it gets like 2 votes and ranks #93 out of 120. The dev is asking for help & feedback on the thread for almost 2 months now and getting no replies, that would be much more helpful.

 

[Darth Roxor]

Knights of the Chalice 2 currently has 98 reviews on steam. I wonder how many it had when it was included in the relevant GOTY poll, but I wouldn't be surprised if it was A Game No One Ever Heard Of (tm).

 

[luj1]

But I still think this is outside the goals of a GOTY poll. If you want to support a game with 12 mixed reviews on Steam you should buy it and review it, not push to add it to the voting

Much of the stuff you included has mixed ratings and not many reviews. Faggot.

 

[Infinitron]

So, it's time to do the Codex RPG of the Year polls again! Once again, I took Abu Antar's list, removed games with less than 50 reviews and added some he was missing, like Corpus Edax and Felvidek.

LIST OF GAMES

7th Domain:Tree of Chaos

9th Dawn Remake

Alaloth: Champions of the Four Kingdoms

Anomaly Collapse

Arco

Arisen Force: Life Devotee

AWAKEN - Astral Blade

Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden

Baten Kaitos I & II HD Remaster

Beloved Rapture

Beyond Galaxyland

Black Myth: Wu Kong

Bloomtown: A Different Story

C.A.R.D.S. RPG: The Misty Battlefield

Capes

Card-en-Ciel

Caribbean Legend - Open World RPG

Cat Quest III

Caves of Qud

Chrono Ark

Classified: France '44

Corpse Keeper

CORPUS EDAX

Creator of Another World

Crown Wars: The Black Prince

Cryptmaster

Dawnsbury Days

Dead Season

Deathbound

Depersonalization

Dokimon: Quest

Dragon Age: The Veilguard

Dragon Quest III HD-2D Remake

Dragon Quest Monsters: The Dark Prince

Dragon Ruins

Dragon's Dogma 2

Drakkar Crew

Dread Delusion

Drova - Forsaken Kin

Dungeons of Blood and Dream

Dungeons of Hinterberg

Eiyuden Chronicle: Hundred Heroes

Elmarion: the Lost Temple

Enotria: The Last Song

FAIRY TAIL 2

Fairy Tail: Dungeons

Fallout: London

FANTASIAN Neo Dimension

Felvidek

Final Fantasy XVI

Flint - Treasure of Oblivion

Flintlock: The Siege of Dawn

Flowstone Saga

Forgotten but Unbroken

Forgotten Mines

FOUNTAINS

Geneforge 2 - Infestation

Gestalt: Steam & Cinder

Gladiator Guild Manager

Glorious Companions

Gobs and Gods

Gorgon Shield

Granblue Fantasy: Relink

GUNDAM BREAKER 4

Halls of Torment

Inkulinati

Keylocker Turn Based Cyberpunk Action

King Arthur: Legion IX

Kingsgrave

Kingsvein

Knock on the Coffin Lid

Last Epoch

Legend of Mortal

Like A Dragon: Infinite Wealth

Ludus Mortis

MEGATON MUSASHI W: WIRED

Meifumado

Metal Slug Tactics

Metaphor ReFantazio

Monster Hunter Stories

Morbid: The Lords of Ire

Mortal Glory 2

My Lovely Empress

Neon Blood

Nine Tereasures of Liuyin

Our Adventurer Guild

Paper Lily - Chapter 1

Path of Achra

Persona 3 Reload

Pixel Noir

Reverse Collapse: Code Name Bakery

REYNATIS

Rising Lords

Riviera: The Promised Land

Robin Hood - Sherwood Builders

Rogue Waters

Romancing SaGa 2: Revenge of the Seven

Rum & Gun

SaGa Emerald Beyond

SAND LAND

Saturn

Scarmonde

SCP: The Expedition

Secrets of Grindea

Shin Megami Tensei V: Vengeance

Shiren the Wanderer: The Mystery Dungeon of Serpentcoil Island

SKALD: Against the Black Priory

Slice & Dice

SOF: Enemy from the future

Sonar Shock

Songs of Conquest

Sovereign Syndicate

Space Prison

Steamworld Heist II

Stolen Realm

Stories from the Outbreak

Subterrain: Mines of Titan

SWORD ART ONLINE Fractured Daydream

Tactical Breach Wizards

Terra Memoria

Terra Randoma

The Black Grimoire: Cursebreaker

The Edge of Allegoria

The Legend of Heroes: Trails through Daybreak

The Matchless KungFu

The Nameless: Slay Dragon

The Secret of Varonis

The Thaumaturge

The World of Kungfu: Dragon and Eagle

Three Kingdoms Zhao Yun

Tokyo Clanpool

Tower of Mask

Traveller's Hymn

USC: Counterforce

Vendir: Plague of Lies

Visions of Mana

Wantless : Solace at World’s End

Withering Rooms

Wizardry: Proving Grounds of the Mad Overlord

Worlds of Aria

Ys X: Nordics

Zoria: Age of Shattering

古龙风云录

Surprisingly, the list is actually shorter than last year. I'll leave this here until the weekend to see if we're missing anything important, then ask Twiglard to make the GOTY poll.

From the Codex front page:

Dawn of the Ashen Queen
StarCrawlers Chimera
Monsters of Mican
Labyrinth: The Wizard's Cat

Another one:

Empyre: Earls of the Deep Earth

 

[Grauken]

Another one:

Empyre: Earls of the Deep Earth

Lmao, 1 review, are you trying to troll Felipe?

 

[The Wall]

I'll have to do this and other things on my own. Soon. This ain't how you do GOTY

 

[Infinitron]

Another one:

Empyre: Earls of the Deep Earth

Lmao, 1 review, are you trying to troll Felipe?

Not intentionally, but I agree it's indistinguishable from trolling.

I searched the front page news using the forum rather than Google to see if I'd missed anything and that came up.

 

[Shaki]

https://store.steampowered.com/tags/en/Hentai/

Don't forget to include all the games here

 

[Moonrise]

Ahead of the voting I'd like to thank BioWare for making the year memorable, and Hans Zimmer for providing the score.

 

[Konjad]

I'm old and forgot all requirements, do games count when they enter Early Access or when they reach 1.0?

 

[Grauken]

I'm old and forgot all requirements, do games count when they enter Early Access or when they reach 1.0?

1.0