Ban Theodora and promote Rusty to Admin replacing Infinitron.
I asked Theodora: "Are you a part of this community?". She replied with: "I don't care."
This is something that you can verify in the Shoutbox Archives, as they are (still) up.
I believe that was a moment of 100% honesty on her part.
Let's analyze the situation:
1. your "opponent"/interlocutor cannot be reasoned with, because they do not care
2. you cannot/are unable to attack back, because those are the rules of the game at that moment
What does this situation remind you of?
To me it reminds me of that moment about a quarter of a century ago, when my bully was beating the crap out of me for entertainment, while ridiculing me for playing "nerdy games".
What was the solution at the time?
Just walk away. I picked up my bag with schoolbooks and D&D manuals, and walked away. And I did that until he got bored.
Essentially: if you remove the input of the problem, there is no output. Ignore Theodora and Mebrilla, and there is no drama. Hell, there won't even be a reason for her to be a mod, if most people can't read her lines.
When a jock, or a pretty princess come into a nerd's territory... this is how you play the game.
Do you think they didn't laugh when Rusty got banned?