herostratus said:
Therefore, even if you lean back and just watch (e. g. voting for C) the conservatives will likely win anyhow. The only difference is that they win less overwhelming, and there is a larger amount of bloodshed and instability in the process.
^^ this guy was onto something
___________________________
Anyways. Autocracies are too unstable, since they are so dependent upon the ruler in question. Representative democracy will be too hard to swallow now seeing as the government that led us into this mess in the first place was a representative demcoracy. That leaves only oligarchy.
For the government style, I don't think a theocracy would be too successful - there has been no recorded instances so far where religion has played a significant role in this story, so I doubt the average codexer is ready for a theocracy. My guess is they will just not understand the concept submission to religion.
Populism should be discarded as well, since so many of the codexers just hates each other guts, meaning that the different factions would use every opportunity to use the government as a tool for hurting it's opponents. I could hardly imagine the party of the neoliberal capital approving of increased education funding in the conservative capital, for example, no matter how prudent it would be as a policy. Therefore a populist government at this stage would tear our nation apart.
That leaves either mercantile or militaristic. Since we have just come out of a from a huge civil war I think it is safe to say that both the space bugs and the commonwealth have an advantage when it comes to mercantile stuff. Not to mention the fact that trade requires a good deal of trust, cooperation and freedom of movement and interaction, something our fractured society isn't very good at to say the least. In other words, basing our state on finance will be creating our state on what we atm do worst.
That leaves only militaristic. This is the only good choice IMO. Not only does the strict military hierarchy leave less chance for splinter groups and factions, but it also ensures that military power is aligned with political power.
Also we need to consider that our territories are ripe for the taking by any interested party, which is obviously an unacceptable situation.
So, in conclusion:
B. Oligarchy
and
A. Militaristic
Edit: I don't know if this is legal, but if the supporters of Militarism aren't anywhere close to winning by the time voting is almost over, I change the vote to
C, mercantilism, which is the second best alternative.
Edit 2: Militarism has no chance of winning, so the second vote is flopped to
C. Mercantile