Ok, I'm at page 54 of this thread so far (I don't do first-day purchases, so I wait until the honeymoon is over), but I caved in and started playing two days ago.
I have never played a game that is more fitting to the Codex. This is the number one game for us. It might be based on Baldur's Gate, but it's much better.
I was thinking of making Dragon Quest XI my game of the year, but it is no contest compared to this.
Ok, off to playing some more, and catching up with this thread in between.
Indeed:
1) It is unfinished and buggy as fuck
2) It is written by Avellone (This means it is a masterpiece. Witcher 3 was not written by Avellone, means it is garbage. This is the thought process of the average codexer)
3) It is based on a convoluted fork of a 15 year old edition of DnD rules, and no attempt at adopting it to computer gameplay was made
4) Bonus points because it is an indie production made somewhere in Siberia, company offices inside an old Gulag or something. Gives prestige
5) Extra bonus points because it has no proper tutorial and normal mortals can't find the patience to trudge through this shit. This makes it RPGCodex game of the century right there. It's always great if you can be a poser in front of your friends and can claim they missed out on the best game of humanity because they don't have your supposed intelligence, smarts, and good genes. It makes you feel superior, makes you forget the fact that you are a short fat nerd with a dwarf beard, man boobs, and no life.
Yup, perfect game for the codex.