Cleveland Mark Blakemore
Golden Era Games
Strange how experiences differ: Samhain stayed in my own memory as a place of great evil, the name alone lets me imagine again the endless halls and dark corners, the unholy depths and sinister caverns of this cursed city and its lurking madness. I wasn't expecting something thoroughly lovecraftian however so I wasn't disappointed - on the contrary: The atrocious beast at the end was horrifying for me, its lair was a place of terror and I still hear the unnatural and blasphemous sounds it emitted. While I really admire good old H.P. I'm glad Samhain wasn't just copying/pasting from the master. This way it's a respectful nod towards the venerable Rhode Islander and I'm fine with that.
I don't mean that it should be literally lovecraftian, just that the build up and hype are not in proportion to what you actually encounter there. Maybe having a difficult fight with waves of attackers shortly after entering Samhain would be a good idea too.
I was thinking of sticking the Shoggoth in there for a one-time big encounter instead of just the Roach Canyon, to get a bit more use out of it.