Oh, man, what a turkey! Fallout 4 feels like a decent tech demo pretending to be a game...
I find the game extremely frustrating in two ways - first, Bethesda clearly didn't learn from their mistakes in Fallout 3; and second, the game is just a pain to play.
- The game defaults to the controller if you have one and doesn't even respond to the keyboard & mouse... WTF?
- Like in Fallout 3, the interface is absolutely abysmal. I dread opening any menu.
- The HUD is hideous beyond belief... Even the main menu of the game is spectacularly ugly.
- The main plot is again dumb and tries too hard to give you feelz.
- Combat is retarded and consists of VATS -> headshot -> wait for action points -> repeat. There is no reason to do anything else. If I want to play a shooter I'll go to the Steam library and load up a read shooter. So just like in Fallout 3.
- Aiming in VATS is annoying and difficult. Fair enough. But VATS is only a slow and not a pause, and so I frequently suffer damage while merely trying to aim at the proper body part... WTF?
- Sometimes VATS give me a high change-to-hit, but the PC just empties his magazine into a wall once I click "shoot".
- It takes a few seconds between switching screens on computer consoles. This is incredibly frustrating and makes me avoid consoles like the plague.
- Worse, consoles tend to be infodumps. The developer has voiced every single line in the game - why torture us with printed infodumps? Can't we just have tapes lying on the floor like in other modern games? If I want to read a story I'll go read a book.
- Inventory management is a huge pain and I didn't see a vendor in three hours of play.
- The city-building mini-game is retarded and scavenging is extra dull.
- The NPCs are all wooden and boring. No Sulik here.
- The dog breaks the immersion completely. It constantly eats up mininukes, hails of bullets, and severe mauling - without as much as wincing.
- Progression is completely fucked. A couple of hours into the game I was assaulted by a raider clad in power armor and armed with a mininuke. I shot him to death with my popgun. This was an encounter next to a dungeon that I had to clear for an early quest. The dungeon itself was trivial. At least the Deathclaw at the Museum was a quest encounter...
- Speaking of which, what's this mininuke weapon? A nuke - even a mininuke - would wipe out an entire neighborhood. Why am I being shot at with mininukes?
- There are no cities. In Skyrim, within ten minutes of leaving the intro you enter a real little hamlet. And within the first two hours of gameplay you reach a proper city - one of many. In Fallout 4 the wasteland truly is a wasteland.
- The RPG system is incomprehensible. You have two builds - you can either put points into Perception and Agility and take %dmg perks, or you can put points into Perception and Agility and take %dmg perks. Most stats and perks are useless. The perks menu is gorgeous, though, a work of art.
The only good things about the game are the graphics (quite nice) and the attention to detail poured into the construction of the game-world.
Skyrim was a good game, but this one isn't. For that matter, Fallout 4 is basically Fallout 3 redux. It's the same thing with improved graphics. And that's the problem. There were only two things we could realistically ask for - a game which fixes Fallout 3's problems (like New Vegas) or at least a good Bethesda game (like Skyrim). But Bethesda gave us neither of those two things.
Lesson learned, then - no more preorders. I'll beat this title out of habit and principle... But yeah, in the grander scheme of things Fallout 4 is a failure.