Restarting for the 10th or so time* and, after all these playthroughs, I think the most logical conclusion to take, if one is devoid of fanboyism and expectations, and only digests what the game offers you, is that Yharnam as we experience it is just another layer of nightmare. Really. Think with me. The only time you experience the real world (aside from the ending where you wake up with the sun rising) is the very beginning of the intro where you're signing down the contract and laying down on the table. After that you pass out and everything from this point on is a fucking dream/nightmare - and the blood minister even TELLS IT TO YOU. If you don't believe me, notice this:
- There are no "little ones" in the real world. The first time you meet them, right in the intro cutscene,
you're already dreaming.
- The animation when you use the Hunter Slip of paper to return to the dream looks like you're are trying to wake up, and then you fucking vanish!
- The game is all about travelling between dream worlds/layers Lovecraft Dreamcycle-way, and the modus by which you do it is identical to what you do enter and exit Yharnam itself. IF Yharnam was the real world, it's only logical that you should interact with it in a different manner than the other dream worlds/layers (perhaps going to sleep in a bed? Oh you don't need because YOURE ALREADY SLEEPING IN THE CLINIC'S BED THIS WHOLE TIME!)
- OLD YHARNAM IS FUCKING BURNING! THERE ARE FIRE LIGHT UP ALL AROUND IT. How can this be if, according to the snippets of lore around, Old Yharnam was burned a "long time ago" (at least decades but it could be centuries!)? The only explanation is: this is a dream.
- Same for Chalice Dungeons. The way you enter and exit it is the same as all other dream worlds, by teleporting. If this was the real world, these catacombs would accessible right at the Byrgenwerth University backyard. In fact, judging by the scenery, I would say the place where you fight the Shadows of Yharnam is the best candidate spot for the excavation site that leads to the tombs.
- Some gadgets are totally "dream-tech" based: the Lead Elixir is said to be an essence taken from nightmares where the host is scared of something and can't run or runs very slowly. If this works in Yharnam, is because the city is in a nightmare and not the real world.
etc.
I think the intention by the authors was to let everything ambiguous on purpose, so the game has this dreamlike uncertainty to make players question it and come up with distinct interpretations. But I think there are more evidence for Yharnam being in the dream world than the contrary. I don't know how this dream-version relates to the supposed real-historic version, but I think there's a strong relation, maybe distorting real history just slightly (which explains this Old Yharnam dream-version still having fire burning).
*with a woman this time, just to see the female version of clothes
I bought a PS4 only for Bloodborne. Best decision I made under this shitty sky. Now the sky is full of a menacing moon that wants me to jump right in the emptiness of the cosmos. What a friendly and comforting presence
Same as me. And I can assure you I'm yet to find a better game in this console. Welcome to the fold, hunter.