Drog Black Tooth
Self-Ejected
- Joined
- Feb 20, 2008
- Messages
- 2,636
Nice job, Athiska.
I'd like to note, that one of our main policies is to not change anything for the sake of "sounding better", "being less confusing", etc. We're only hunting typos/mistakes.
I'm not sure, but I think we should stop here with our little project. It's getting more and more complicated. There's a lot of inconsistencies, like not capitalized proper nouns and such, and it's pain in the ass to track all of them down. Also since I'm not a native speaker, I'm not very effective as the editor, I'm afraid.
I'm sorry...
In addition, I'm required to make important decisions, that would significantly change dialogs, and I don't think I'm in position to make such decisions.
Ellipses are used like that throughout all dialogs. There are very long ellipses, ellipses with spaces or exclamation points before or after them, etc. Very, very messy.Athiska said:01090Hadrian_the_Archaeologist.dlg
I think I read somewhere in the past that ellipses were to have a space after them. There's many, many ellipses here, and all have no spaces. It looks intentional.
Probably. Although, they appear in many dialogs sometimes capitalized, sometimes not, but mostly not capitalized. "High Acolyte" in Alexander's dialog is capitalized, "high priest" is not, but it should be. Church Archaeologist and Church Historian should be capitalized as well. What a mess!Athiska said:Apart from that, I recommended capitalizing the Church, Council, Eye of Kraka-tur, and Elders as they refer to specific people or groups.
I suppose they meant "I can't say I could help you".Athiska said:Line 167: I don’t understand it; a bad edit? The line is, “Right. Well, I can't say as I could help you.” Maybe it was meant to be, “Well, I can’t say, as I can’t help you.” or “Well, I can’t say, and I couldn’t help you.”
I don't think so. This is not a mistake.Athiska said:Line 224: Apart from the ellipses without spaces, I recommend changing the description “[he trails off...]” to “[He trails off.]” It’s like an indecisive narrator.
Again, I don't think so, ellipses are used to make pauses in the middle of sentences many times in this dialog.Athiska said:Line 229: Considering that Hadrian is probably starting a new sentence every time, “I have no idea...this discovery...I'm speechless.” should be, “I have no idea... This discovery... I'm speechless.”
Line 235: “One of the objects I have here is the Finger of Mannox...there is a legend associated with it.” should be, “One of the objects I have here is the Finger of Mannox... There is a legend associated with it.”
"Monster's".Athiska said:Line 301: Capitalize “Eye of Kraka-tur,” “Council,” and add a space after the ellipsis.
“No... I mean it's REALLY the [b[Eye[/b] of Kraka-tur! When the Council was banishing him, he put up quite a struggle. Somehow the monsters Eye got put out, and someone found it as they were cleaning up. Dreadful creature, Kraka-tur was. If you ask Alexander about who's been banished over the year's, he'll tell you the story...”
No, it's OK.Athiska said:Line 373: Because it’s a little confusing without it (the text never specifies which finger the Finger of Mannox is, here), add “hand” or something suitable to the line.
{[Hadrian turns white...] Missing a finger. His right finger? [He holds his hand up and points to it.]
I'd like to note, that one of our main policies is to not change anything for the sake of "sounding better", "being less confusing", etc. We're only hunting typos/mistakes.
I'm not sure, but I think we should stop here with our little project. It's getting more and more complicated. There's a lot of inconsistencies, like not capitalized proper nouns and such, and it's pain in the ass to track all of them down. Also since I'm not a native speaker, I'm not very effective as the editor, I'm afraid.
I'm sorry...
In addition, I'm required to make important decisions, that would significantly change dialogs, and I don't think I'm in position to make such decisions.