Putting the 'role' back in role-playing games since 2002.
Donate to Codex
Good Old Games
  • Welcome to rpgcodex.net, a site dedicated to discussing computer based role-playing games in a free and open fashion. We're less strict than other forums, but please refer to the rules.

    "This message is awaiting moderator approval": All new users must pass through our moderation queue before they will be able to post normally. Until your account has "passed" your posts will only be visible to yourself (and moderators) until they are approved. Give us a week to get around to approving / deleting / ignoring your mundane opinion on crap before hassling us about it. Once you have passed the moderation period (think of it as a test), you will be able to post normally, just like all the other retards.

The Witcher 3 GOTY Edition

2house2fly

Magister
Joined
Apr 10, 2013
Messages
1,877
No, "all the other stuff was great" is just wrong. The progression system is shit, the itemization is the worst i've seen in a "RPG" and the level-design is just absent (to name just a few).

And the combat has nothing to do with Dark Souls (no stamina management, contextual attacks, only one weapon ...).
Itemization worst you've ever seen in an "RPG"? Have you not seen any fucking bethesda game ever? Now quit fucking exaggerating.

And he was referring to the spam rolling across half the room, and swinging your weapon wildly, then backing off before a counter attack from the enemy, that occurs for most low skill souls players.
I don't know if I would describe the itemization as the worst I've ever seen in an RPG, but the fact that functionally you only have one weapon(maybe you can build your character around using bombs or spells but IME they're there to supplement the sword fighting, not replace it) certainly doesn't help. It also doesn't help that, from what I remember anyway, very few items had any interesting effects beyond higher damage and a 5% chance to inflict a status ailment.

I can't comment on the story as it is intended to be the final chapter of a series of books I haven't read, and video games I haven't played. It's probably great if you have read the books and played the games, and therefore have a basis to get invested in the characters.
 

Old Hans

Arcane
Joined
Oct 10, 2011
Messages
2,125
If anyone plays any of the witcher games for loot and number whoring, they are doing it wrong. That does not excuse that these aspects are not the best ever, but still, the focus was elsewhere.

the problems is they added all that dumb shit. The systems in the game were just a big mess. Witcher 3 took it to a whole new level. Like someone on the team thought it was a cool idea to make every single box and shelf lootable for rope ladders and ladles. No game needs lootable ladles or rope ladders.
 

anvi

Prophet
Village Idiot
Joined
Oct 12, 2016
Messages
8,408
Location
Kelethin
No, "all the other stuff was great" is just wrong. The progression system is shit, the itemization is the worst i've seen in a "RPG" and the level-design is just absent (to name just a few).

And the combat has nothing to do with Dark Souls (no stamina management, contextual attacks, only one weapon ...).
What progression system? You get levels and you get skill points each level, kind of like every other RPG ever. And the itemization is fine, you get regular upgrades and can craft specific entire sets based on how you want to play. And there are no levels to design, it was a big open world that was better than anything Bethesda ever made and felt very realistic. My only complaint with the world is that it was all mostly the same, rural and swampy. I play an MMO I get to go to deserts, snowy areas, volcanoes, etc. Single player RPGs never seem to match that. But mostly it was really good, just bad combat.

If anyone plays any of the witcher games for loot and number whoring, they are doing it wrong. That does not excuse that these aspects are not the best ever, but still, the focus was elsewhere.
The focus is on quests and story, which in TW3's case aren't good at all
What RPG has better quests?

If anyone plays any of the witcher games for loot and number whoring, they are doing it wrong. That does not excuse that these aspects are not the best ever, but still, the focus was elsewhere.

the problems is they added all that dumb shit. The systems in the game were just a big mess. Witcher 3 took it to a whole new level. Like someone on the team thought it was a cool idea to make every single box and shelf lootable for rope ladders and ladles. No game needs lootable ladles or rope ladders.
That's just materials for crafting. If you don't like crafting, don't loot ladles and shit.
 

Lord_Potato

Arcane
Glory to Ukraine
Joined
Nov 24, 2017
Messages
10,925
Location
Free City of Warsaw
If anyone plays any of the witcher games for loot and number whoring, they are doing it wrong. That does not excuse that these aspects are not the best ever, but still, the focus was elsewhere.
The focus is on quests and story, which in TW3's case aren't good at all

Some quests are great (Bloody Baron, the mages of Novigrad, Towerful of Mice etc.). There are some simple Witcher jobs (go there, find monster, kill it, come back and claim bounty), some fetch quests, but not too much.

The story in Wild Hunt have troubles due to poor pacing, but the expansions are better in this regard. Especially Heart of Stone is a great story and it plays out in a masterful way.
 

MoonlitKnight

Educated
Joined
Nov 11, 2014
Messages
60
If anyone plays any of the witcher games for loot and number whoring, they are doing it wrong. That does not excuse that these aspects are not the best ever, but still, the focus was elsewhere.
The focus is on quests and story, which in TW3's case aren't good at all
What RPG has better quests?
.
No need to really look far,
both Witcher 1 and 2 had quests in which you actually needed to solve the mystery or whatever, not just press the "WITCHER SENSE" key and follow the footprints or trail of breadcrumbs or anything. I dont know how can people view this as good quest design
 

Lord_Potato

Arcane
Glory to Ukraine
Joined
Nov 24, 2017
Messages
10,925
Location
Free City of Warsaw
If anyone plays any of the witcher games for loot and number whoring, they are doing it wrong. That does not excuse that these aspects are not the best ever, but still, the focus was elsewhere.
The focus is on quests and story, which in TW3's case aren't good at all
What RPG has better quests?
.
No need to really look far,
both Witcher 1 and 2 had quests in which you actually needed to solve the mystery or whatever, not just press the "WITCHER SENSE" key and follow the footprints or trail of breadcrumbs or anything. I dont know how can people view this as good quest design

There are quests in Witcher 3 where witcher senses will not solve the investigation for you: e.g. the vampire quest in Novigrad or the canibal quest up north.
 

Quillon

Arcane
Joined
Dec 15, 2016
Messages
5,297
If anyone plays any of the witcher games for loot and number whoring, they are doing it wrong. That does not excuse that these aspects are not the best ever, but still, the focus was elsewhere.
The focus is on quests and story, which in TW3's case aren't good at all
What RPG has better quests?
.
No need to really look far,
both Witcher 1 and 2 had quests in which you actually needed to solve the mystery or whatever, not just press the "WITCHER SENSE" key and follow the footprints or trail of breadcrumbs or anything. I dont know how can people view this as good quest design

There are quests in Witcher 3 where witcher senses will not solve the investigation for you: e.g. the vampire quest in Novigrad or the canibal quest up north.

Too bad there are so few; tho Carnal Sins was pretty easy to figure out and still Geralt acted surprised IIRC and the cannibal quest came with HoS.
 

Danikas

Arcane
Joined
Jun 15, 2017
Messages
1,605
If anyone plays any of the witcher games for loot and number whoring, they are doing it wrong. That does not excuse that these aspects are not the best ever, but still, the focus was elsewhere.
The focus is on quests and story, which in TW3's case aren't good at all
What RPG has better quests?
.
No need to really look far,
both Witcher 1 and 2 had quests in which you actually needed to solve the mystery or whatever, not just press the "WITCHER SENSE" key and follow the footprints or trail of breadcrumbs or anything. I dont know how can people view this as good quest design

There are quests in Witcher 3 where witcher senses will not solve the investigation for you: e.g. the vampire quest in Novigrad or the canibal quest up north.

Too bad there are so few; tho Carnal Sins was pretty easy to figure out and still Geralt acted surprised IIRC and the cannibal quest came with HoS.

Nope Carnal Sins is a quest from main game.
 

Ivan

Arcane
Joined
Jun 22, 2013
Messages
7,757
Location
California
I first played this for 30 some hours dropped it to shitty frames, replaying now with 1080 HOLEEEEEEEE SHIT this is gorgeous.

It's crazy how handcrafted every quest is. The only one I felt was lackluster was the Dwarf Mugging quest.
 

MoonlitKnight

Educated
Joined
Nov 11, 2014
Messages
60
If anyone plays any of the witcher games for loot and number whoring, they are doing it wrong. That does not excuse that these aspects are not the best ever, but still, the focus was elsewhere.
The focus is on quests and story, which in TW3's case aren't good at all
What RPG has better quests?
.
No need to really look far,
both Witcher 1 and 2 had quests in which you actually needed to solve the mystery or whatever, not just press the "WITCHER SENSE" key and follow the footprints or trail of breadcrumbs or anything. I dont know how can people view this as good quest design

There are quests in Witcher 3 where witcher senses will not solve the investigation for you: e.g. the vampire quest in Novigrad or the canibal quest up north.
They're the very exception to the rule
 
Joined
Dec 5, 2010
Messages
1,620
FCR3 - Immersion and Gameplay Tweaks released! I felt FCR2 was a must-have for TW2, even moreso than jsawyer's mod for FNV.

INTRODUCTION

Hey, I'm a senior gameplay designer and I worked on The Witcher3 and both expansion packs. This mod used to be a personal set of tweaks and fixes meant to spice up my first The Witcher 3 playthrough after releasing the game. Being in creation for more than half a year and enjoyed during >300h playthrough I thought that I might share it with witcher community. Mod doesn't aim for any deep and intrusive changes, instead it is meant to maintain original feeling of the game, sometimes going closer to original intention behind the designs. It focuses mainly on fixing immersion breakers, buffing underperforming skills and items, cosmetic changes and bugfixing. It also fixes few instances of items and abilities that made Geralt (nearly) immortal and removed all the challenge from the game.

CHANGELOG

Immersion
Bunch of features that added to ‘wow’ factor and changes for things that bothered me.
• Metamorphosis mutation effect "Witcher Senses now increase visibility in dark places without the use of potions works" works without the mutation. In combat it works automatically, while outside of combat it can be activated in focus mode. Witchers see in the dark. All of them, no potions needed. It’s in lore.
• Added reaction to stealing for commoners. There are two severities of reactions and two results for each of them depending on npc AI. Commoners will react depending on the priority of tasks they are undergoing at the moment. The effect is that some of the npcs will ignore you stealing stuff, others will call you out on it, some will just stare. There will be also rare cases when someone will be become intimidated, cover in fear or possibly run away. The effect is especially visible in Novigrad, less in Skellige and least in Toussaint, where even guards ignore player stealing.
• Increased minimal height from which fall damage starts to be applied.
• Made Ciri immune to damage while she's performing special 'teleport' charged attack. Could be considered as a bugfix.
• Allied NPCs (followers) deal full damage to enemies (used to deal minimal damage).
• Buffed sorceress and witcher followers damage. These are the most powerful characters in the setting, you should feel that now.
• Reduced level bonus of guards from player level plus random 11-13 to player level plus random 0-5. A random guard shouldn't pose a threat to legendary witcher.
• Sped up animations of flying monsters falling down after being shot from the sky.
• Added fall damage on ground contact for monsters that were shot from the sky. Damage depends on the height from which they fall.
• Allowed to bounce majority of the physical projectiles with Aard hit.
• Signs buffed by Flood of Anger skill cause enemy explosive dismemberment on kill.
• Sorceresses now dismember enemies on kill.
• Fixed majority of rare cases where Geralt jumped after hitting ground while playing death animation.
• Fixed some of the cases for sorceresses where spell visual effect remained on hand after combat. Still not sure if all instances were fixed but should be better.


Character development
Multiple changes that aim at bringing back the original intended feeling to character development and alchemy builds. Initially skills were designed as a single point investments. The excess of skillpoints player was given was meant to encourage swapping skills depending on the enemies and situations. To bring back that feeling max levels of skills were reduced giving more bang for the buck instead of small percent increases. Additionally there are few changes bringing high toxicity Euphoria build down to be on par with other builds and buffs for mutations that didn’t feel strong or unique enough.
• Decreased skills max levels (most had 5, now 3) and adjusted stats to retain the same balance. Utility skills like slowdown on aiming now have only 1 level.
• Nerfed Acquired Tolerance skill to grant 0.5 Toxicity point per level to prevent safe activation of more than 3 decoctions at the same time in end game.
• Quen doesn't remove damage over time effects on cast, instead it protects player while DoTs consume the shield. Resistances on armors should matter more now.
• Reduced healing from damage on alternate Quen from 100% of received damage to 0.1 * damage * Spell Power. This mechanic was clearly overpowered and made player nearly immortal.
• Decreased toxicity overdose damage threshold from 75 to 50. That was the initial original idea for toxicity handling encouraging player to take risk and correctly time potion use.
• Equalized out of combat and combat toxicity drop rate (used to be twice as fast).
• Crippling Strikes skill: Deals regular bleeding effect damage that cannot go below the dmg value specified in skill description. Also effect duration was increased from 5 to 10 seconds to match the duration of regular bleeding. General idea is that effect originating from skill shouldn't be weaker than bleeding from item.
• Adrenaline Rush mutation: When at maximum Vitality, Adrenaline Points drop after 4s delay. Introduced new potential skill combos and play styles instead of another percentage damage buff.
• Deadly Counter mutation: A counterattack immediately triggers a finisher with a chance based on the number of Adrenaline Points. Opponents immune to counterattacks are not affected. Used to work only on opponents below 25% health.
• Toxic Blood mutation: doubled the returned damage value (3% per toxicity point, was 1.5%) to compensate for reducing maximum achievable toxicity.


NPCs
Couple of bugfixes and removing arbitrary stat bonuses.
• Removed huge arbitrary stat buffs on enemies with skull icons. They are already higher level than player, that alone makes them more difficult.
• Allowed to parry and counterattack enemies with skull icons.
• Fixed leshen root damage being a fixed value throughout the whole game. It's taken from his melee attack damage so it scales with enemy level.
• Made bird swarm attacks ignore armor. Leshen bird attacks dealt zero damage starting from mid-game.
• Fixed sprigan's root ground attack dealing no damage.
• Restored monster essence (silver health bar) regeneration (mostly for werewolves). It was temporarily disabled at some point in implementation and never brought back.
• Fixed discrepancies between NG+ and base game xml files, like missing ability definitions, ability tags, etc. These potentially caused minor bugs in enemy stats in NG+.
• Rats are not affected by enemy upscaling option.


General items
Bunch of small changes that put more emphasis on some of the gameplay mechanics that didn’t work as originally intended due to balancing issues.
• Increased random range of item levels rolled for quest rewards. You might end up with an item you cannot use yet, but at least you'll get a guaranteed upgrade on level up.
• Increased stat debuff on damaged items. Value depends on game difficulty level with 50% debuff on highest difficulty. Repairing items matter now.
• Increased amount of gold given in quests where it made sense (Baron should be more generous, etc.). Didn't touch the mini-quests.
• Reduced the amount of healing per second from food but increased healing duration. Overall it's a slight buff for food without Gourmet perk and a significant nerf with it. Swallow and White Raffard potions are intended healing in combat, not chicken sandwiches.


Witcher sets
Changes are focused on fixing near immortality issue coming from high rending (monster) damage reduction combined with Protective Coating skill. Also there are two sets partially focusing on buffing alchemy builds. Mod moves alchemy bonuses to Manticore set making it a dedicated alchemy set and introduces new bonuses and playstyle to Wolven set. I remember reading about the idea of Wolven set built around bleeding damage on Witcher Reddit, so cheers to the Reddit community.
• Scaled down monster damage resistance on witcher armors where applicable. Upgraded witcher sets used in conjunction with Protective Coating oil used to reach 100% rending damage reduction (some damage still passed due to resistance cap). That shouldn't be the case now. For details on numbers check attached images.
• Enabled grandmaster set bonuses on all witcher sets items in New Game+.
• Moved 3 item Wolven set bonus (bombs are thrown without a delay) and merged it with 3 item Manticore set bonus (bombs are affected by critical hit chance and critical hit damage).
• Reduced Manticore set Toxicity bonus from 30 (and more on NG+) to 20, to prevent safe activation of more than 3 decoctions at the same time in end game.
• Moved 6 item Wolven set bonus (3 different oils can be applied to a sword) to Fixative alchemy skill. Should make Fixative skill a more interesting choice in character development.
• New Wolven set 3 item bonus: Each stack of Bleeding effect applied to enemies increases sword damage by 1% for each piece of the set.
• New Wolven set 6 item bonus: Each Adrenaline Point increases number of possible stacks of Bleeding effect that can be applied to single opponent. With new set bonuses Wolven set tries to fulfil the fantasy of specialized Damage over Time build working well in conjunction with buffed Crippling Strikes skill.


Item upgrades
Buffed every runeword and glyphword about which I thought “I’d never use that when I have that other, better choice”. Beside buffing, Possession runeword had its effect changed because there used to be 2 glyphwords buffing Axii in different ways and 3rd being a sum of previous two, so it just wasn’t interesting enough.
• Rejuvenation runeword: Fatal blows restore 100% stamina (was 25%).
• Dumplings runeword: changed duration bonus to 5x increase in healing speed. With this buff food brought back to the same healing speed as in vanilla game while also having significantly increased effect duration.
• Elation runeword: Fatal blows give 1 Adrenaline point (was 0.1 to 0.25).
• Prolongation runeword: Unblocked blows increases potion duration by 1s (was 0.5s)
• Ignition glyphword: Enemies set alight with Igni have a 100% chance to ignite other enemies within a 2 yard radius. (was 25% chance)
• Rotation glyphword: Igni strikes in a 360 radius (removed "but doesn't induce Burning" tradeoff). When I read 360 radius I thought “cool!”, then I read “but doesn’t induce Burning” and I thought “aww, but that tradeoff makes it useless”.
• Possession glyphword, new effect: When effect of Axii ends, opponent receives damage dependent on effect duration and Sign intensity. Spent long time balancing the damage potential. It’s a nice bonus when you don’t invest in Sign intensity and a killer when you do. It’s very effective at the cost of waiting - you could finish off enemies faster by other means. As a bonus eye candy, enemies that die to Possession effect explode.
• Retribution glyphword: 100% chance for half damage returned (was 30% chance for ⅔ damage returned). A small damage nerf in exchange for consistency and reliability. When you allow yourself to be hit to deal damage, you want it to be reliable, not bet on random chance.
• Eruption glyphword: explosion deals the same damage as rotfiend's explosion added to original damage. Used to be only 50 dmg multiplied by Sign intensity.
• Depletion glyphword: casting Aard depletes enemy’s stamina (was 50% stamina damage). The idea behind the glyphword was to allow player to overcome enemy defence even if he didn’t manage to knock him down (stamina is used for offensive and defensive actions). With just 50% stamina damage enemies could still parry after casting Aard, so it didn’t feel like it made any difference.


Bombs
Bombs deal a decent amount of damage up to the middle of main game and then they fall behind Signs and sword damage becoming useless as damage dealers in end game, both expansions and NG+. These changes aim to make bombs a perfectly viable build if player chooses to invest enough skill points in alchemy build.
• Beside increasing potion duration each active alchemy skill also increases damage of bombs by 5% per skill level.
• Added DoT value scaling with enemy max health on top of existing damage value to Devil's Puffball bomb. This is how majority of other DoTs work in the game.
• Heavy Artillery damage bonus acts as a final damage multiplier calculated after bonus from alchemy skills.
• Doubled damage values of bombs and Pyromancy skill in NG+.
• Moon Dust bombs block abilities of cursed monsters and shapeshifters. These monsters are especially vulnerable to silver.
• Northern Wind bombs block rotfiend enemy types explosive deaths.


Crossbow
Beside the cosmetic improvements the main intention is to make crossbow damage useful but not competing with swords, Signs and bombs unless you invest in crossbow related skills and use high quality bolts.
• Crossbow bolt's damage scales with player level. Damage is dependent on bolt quality.
• Slowed down crossbow bolts when shot underwater.
• Increased crossbow bolts range from 25m to 50m when not underwater.


Potions
Didn’t like the way Blizzard potion was triggered. It was useless in 1v1 monster hunts and boss fights. I wanted to remedy that.
• Blizzard potion now activates slow motion when Geralt is in danger, no need to kill an enemy anymore. To compensate, effect's strength and duration was slightly decreased. Blizzard should be more consistent and easy to use now but also not that overpowered.
• Cat potion grants 5% crit chance bonus. A little bonus that should make Cat potion a bit more useful.

https://www.nexusmods.com/witcher3/mods/2788/?

Seems to have a much smaller scope than FCR2(no controls/animations/economy/enemy changes) but I'm eager to replace ghost mode with it.
 
Last edited:

Sentinel

Arcane
Joined
Nov 18, 2015
Messages
6,823
Location
Ommadawn
Wow, always cool to see a developer of the game release his own mod.

Might run this for my replay of the game soon.
 

Falksi

Arcane
Joined
Feb 14, 2017
Messages
11,034
Location
Nottingham
So I hate TW3, mainly because of it's boring main quest and pointless open world doing nothing but get in the way.

However, simply because I've paid for the expansions & am currently under the weather, I returned to it the past few days to play the expansions.

Now both still suffer from the main issue with the entire game - you aren't really interacting with anything, and most quests you don't really do much other than hold witcher senses button down, & chase that yellow marker around. Yes that's all glued together with some stunningly awesome dialogue, but it's still utterly shite questing which rarely requires any real nouse, thought, or interactions other than following the mechanics from point A to B.

However.......Heart of Stone was a far, far tighter experience than the main game and far, FAR better for it. I still didn't buzz off it massively like so many have, but I saw definite progress from TW3's main campaign.

Now, Blood & Wine. I'm only 5 or so hours into, but here they are REALLY starting to get to grips with it. It's still too bloated & has too much filler, plus the quest issues still reamin as mentioned above, but it's constant injection of fresher elements & general design is far, FAR better than the main campaign. It almost feels worth exploring at times, and the open world - whilst still in desperate need of practical variety (everything is still the usual merchant/quest/etc.) - is at least crafted in a way that feels better.

Be interesting to see how I feel when I finish it, but it looks as if CDPR at least started to recognize where they went wrong in the main campaign.
 

Falksi

Arcane
Joined
Feb 14, 2017
Messages
11,034
Location
Nottingham
Just finished a mini-marathon sesh on it, played it most of the day. Blood & Wine just does SO much better than the main game. I've played a decent chunk of the main quest, & completed the Professor & Loved-Up Knight side quests, and thoroughly enjoyed them all.

The main difference is that they involve you a lot more. The portal puzzle.....is actually a puzzle! Not just following Witcher senses, or that yellow marker, I actually had to stop & work it our. Actual roleplaying at last. Then some actual C&C as part of the Loved-up knight quests. At last key elements of roleplaying that involve the player.

Looking forward to playing more tommorow, and glad that I gave the expansions time after the main quest bored me to tears.

Paul_cz - You've rated a lot of my posts on TW3 negitively, I'd be interested to know what you don't agree with? Didn't you enjoy the expansions?
 

Kitchen Utensil

Guest
Just finished a mini-marathon sesh on it, played it most of the day. Blood & Wine just does SO much better than the main game. I've played a decent chunk of the main quest, & completed the Professor & Loved-Up Knight side quests, and thoroughly enjoyed them all.

The main difference is that they involve you a lot more. The portal puzzle.....is actually a puzzle! Not just following Witcher senses, or that yellow marker, I actually had to stop & work it our. Actual roleplaying at last. Then some actual C&C as part of the Loved-up knight quests. At last key elements of roleplaying that involve the player.

Looking forward to playing more tommorow, and glad that I gave the expansions time after the main quest bored me to tears.

Paul_cz - You've rated a lot of my posts on TW3 negitively, I'd be interested to know what you don't agree with? Didn't you enjoy the expansions?

He's a hopeless, completely retarded fanboy and butthurt Witcherfag who can't be helped.
Best to ignore him imo.
 

Paul_cz

Arcane
Joined
Jan 26, 2014
Messages
2,129
Just finished a mini-marathon sesh on it, played it most of the day. Blood & Wine just does SO much better than the main game. I've played a decent chunk of the main quest, & completed the Professor & Loved-Up Knight side quests, and thoroughly enjoyed them all.

The main difference is that they involve you a lot more. The portal puzzle.....is actually a puzzle! Not just following Witcher senses, or that yellow marker, I actually had to stop & work it our. Actual roleplaying at last. Then some actual C&C as part of the Loved-up knight quests. At last key elements of roleplaying that involve the player.

Looking forward to playing more tommorow, and glad that I gave the expansions time after the main quest bored me to tears.

Paul_cz - You've rated a lot of my posts on TW3 negitively, I'd be interested to know what you don't agree with? Didn't you enjoy the expansions?

The answer lies in the first sentence of your post (from yesterday). The open world in TW3 is fantastic for creating sense of place, atmosphere and actually feeling like Geralt, wandering Witcher. The game would be much worse without it. Although it is not perfect (there should have been a bit more variations in PoI, there should have been Fog of War and no question marks on map), but I still find lot of stuff in your post retarded.
That said I agree expansions were improved further on that front.

Fork, I love you too man.
 
Last edited:

ilitarist

Learned
Illiterate Village Idiot
Joined
Oct 17, 2016
Messages
857
Now, Blood & Wine. I'm only 5 or so hours into, but here they are REALLY starting to get to grips with it. It's still too bloated & has too much filler, plus the quest issues still reamin as mentioned above, but it's constant injection of fresher elements & general design is far, FAR better than the main campaign. It almost feels worth exploring at times, and the open world - whilst still in desperate need of practical variety (everything is still the usual merchant/quest/etc.) - is at least crafted in a way that feels better.

Be interesting to see how I feel when I finish it, but it looks as if CDPR at least started to recognize where they went wrong in the main campaign.

I think they totally aimed at that eventual reaction "CDPR sold us an expansion that is bigger than most RPGs".

They even fixed the gameplay a little. End game in the original campaign was boring on any difficulty. There they've added some interesting monsters requiring actual interaction besides smashing - like all those underground plants dropping bombs and teleporting. Also armies of bandits. And they've added a skill tree that gives you some choice and allows using items from the world instantly adding some depth. And home base giving structure to the loop of your adventures.

They also embraced adventure nature of the game - even more quests do not revolve around fighting and there are many brawls that can't be helped by Witcher skills. It is also gorgeous and sounds great. There are quests that affect the world and reactions.

Frankly it's kinda Fallout 1 of Witcher world. It is tight. Yes, there are still huge sways of empty land - and it's fine I think, gives better atmosphere than the usual open world trope of towns being in a direct visibility of each other. There are too many wild monsters around but you are not required to grind - except for oils.

Another good thing is you can start a new game geared up for the expansions without doing main quest again. It cripples you a little: during the main game you would probably get lots of useful oils and potions. But difficulty feels fine on Death March, there's little of that early game hell you got on that difficulty in the original game.
 

Falksi

Arcane
Joined
Feb 14, 2017
Messages
11,034
Location
Nottingham
Now, Blood & Wine. I'm only 5 or so hours into, but here they are REALLY starting to get to grips with it. It's still too bloated & has too much filler, plus the quest issues still reamin as mentioned above, but it's constant injection of fresher elements & general design is far, FAR better than the main campaign. It almost feels worth exploring at times, and the open world - whilst still in desperate need of practical variety (everything is still the usual merchant/quest/etc.) - is at least crafted in a way that feels better.

Be interesting to see how I feel when I finish it, but it looks as if CDPR at least started to recognize where they went wrong in the main campaign.

I think they totally aimed at that eventual reaction "CDPR sold us an expansion that is bigger than most RPGs".

They even fixed the gameplay a little. End game in the original campaign was boring on any difficulty. There they've added some interesting monsters requiring actual interaction besides smashing - like all those underground plants dropping bombs and teleporting. Also armies of bandits. And they've added a skill tree that gives you some choice and allows using items from the world instantly adding some depth. And home base giving structure to the loop of your adventures.

They also embraced adventure nature of the game - even more quests do not revolve around fighting and there are many brawls that can't be helped by Witcher skills. It is also gorgeous and sounds great. There are quests that affect the world and reactions.

Frankly it's kinda Fallout 1 of Witcher world. It is tight. Yes, there are still huge sways of empty land - and it's fine I think, gives better atmosphere than the usual open world trope of towns being in a direct visibility of each other. There are too many wild monsters around but you are not required to grind - except for oils.

Another good thing is you can start a new game geared up for the expansions without doing main quest again. It cripples you a little: during the main game you would probably get lots of useful oils and potions. But difficulty feels fine on Death March, there's little of that early game hell you got on that difficulty in the original game.

Spot on.

I'm enjoying it so much more than the main game for the reasons you mention. Fights are actually a bit challenging! :) And I'm constantly getting new enemies thrown at me too.

The quest structure rarely feels the same too. The main game was usually - talk - walk - witcher senses - fight - talk - reward. Whereas B&W you never quite know what's coming next.

And it just feels so much better because Geralt is plodding around, taking his time. As opposed to having a false-urgent feel that you should be rushing to save Ciri.
 

Atomkilla

Arcane
Joined
Jul 26, 2011
Messages
715
And it just feels so much better because Geralt is plodding around, taking his time. As opposed to having a false-urgent feel that you should be rushing to save Ciri.


Well...no, not really. You are again in the state of false urgency at some point, particularly at one point of the story.
The rest of the time you aren't in that much of an urgency, but the Duchess doesn't really expect you to fuck around.

That being said, yeah, it's not as jarring. And playing some quests post-ending here isn't that bad either (even though I hate post-ending as a concept in general).
 

As an Amazon Associate, rpgcodex.net earns from qualifying purchases.
Back
Top Bottom